More annual reports from Byggfakta Group:
2023 Reportannual
report
2013
AnnuAl RepoRt 31 December 2013Bell Financial Group limited ABN 59 083 194 763
Contents
ExEcutivE chairman’s rEport
opErating and Financial rEviEw
dirEctors’ rEport
(including corporatE govErnancE statEmEnt
and rEmunEration rEport)
lEad auditor’s indEpEndEncE dEclaration
statEmEnt oF proFit or loss
statEmEnt oF comprEhEnsivE incomE
statEmEnt oF Financial position
statEmEnts oF changEs in Equity
statEmEnt oF cash Flows
notEs to thE Financial statEmEnts
dirEctors’ dEclaration
indEpEndEnt auditor’s rEport
sharEholdEr inFormation
dirEctory
02
04
06
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
64
65
67
69
Bell Financial Group 01
Bell FinanCial Group
limited (asX: BFG) is a
leadinG australian
Full serviCe BrokinG
and FinanCial
advisory Firm with a
stronG traCk reCord
oF providinG hiGh
quality, proFessional
adviCe to private,
institutional and
Corporate investors.
Bell has 13 oFFices coverinG australia
anD oFFices in honG KonG anD lonDon.
02 ExEcutivE chairman’s rEport
last year i suGGesteD
our Business woulD
improve throuGh
2013, enDinG 5 very
DiFFicult years.
that DiD in Fact
happen. low worlD-
wiDe interest rates
have increaseD
the attraction oF
risK assets with
commensurate
BeneFits to
Businesses liKe ours.
executive chairman’s report
03
last year i suggested our business would improve through 2013,
ending 5 very difficult years. that did in fact happen. low world-
wide interest rates have increased the attraction of risk assets
with commensurate benefits to businesses like ours.
net after tax profit for the year was $6.8 million, up from the
previous year's loss of $3.2 million. with one exception, in 2013 all
our businesses generated revenues significantly higher than for
2012. as a result we have been able to declare a final dividend of
1.5 cents per share making a total payout for the year of 2.5 cents.
the other part of our retail offering which has adapted to
changing market conditions is our online broker Bell direct.
this is the technology platform we built from scratch, starting
in 2007. last year for the first time Bell direct recorded a small
pre-tax profit and we're excited. apart from the major banks,
Bell direct is the biggest player in the space. now we are at
break-even the operational leverage is huge; in this business
all our marginal revenues drop to the bottom line (and are likely
to stick there). the platform is highly scalable and also highly
saleable to the large intermediaries as a white label product.
it is possible that very little value is attributed to this part of
BFg since it is under the radar, partly because it's a start up
business and partly because it's (only) a 51% owned subsidiary,
despite the fact BFg has the right to go to 100% ownership. i
have no doubt that as a standalone business Bell direct would
attract a significant valuation. i am confident that in time the
market will come to recognize this.
Finally i would like to acknowledge the contribution of uBs for
the role they played in the long and mutually rewarding research
and distribution arrangement that we first entered into in 2001.
these days there are not many market agreements that have
stood the test of time as that one did.
our managing director alastair provan will now give you more
detail about last year's performance.
Colin m. Bell
Executive chairman
Bell Financial group ltd
as i've said before the tough times were good for BFg in the
sense that they forced us to streamline our business and get the
company 'match fit'. this result demonstrates that point.
From an operational point of view, we have great leverage to
better markets and improving revenues. after we cover costs,
50% of marginal revenues drop to the bottom line (pre-tax) so
we have a high conversion rate of earnings to free cash flow (and
dividends, given our consistent payout policy).
the main risks we face today comprise the ever present market
risk, the relatively new collection of regulatory and compliance
risks and the risk that we do not constantly adapt to changing
client requirements.
there is not a lot we can do about market risk except for preserving
the strength of our balance sheet. other than debt in the margin
lending business we operate on a cash in the bank basis.
regulatory and compliance risks for retail brokers today are high
and our policy is to spend as much time and effort as is needed
to ensure we are always a compliant market participant and that
we continually try to fulfil our 'know your client' obligations. we
believe we are on top of these challenges but we know the job is
never done.
as far as being in front of the curve and adapting to changing
client requirements, we think we are in good shape. our
institutional business has a transparent remuneration structure
like no other in the market and partly as a result, is able to
punch way above its weight. in the full service retail market we
think we are perfectly positioned to meet all the needs of our
very large client base.
last week we announced our new research and distribution
deal with citi. Because they are a huge global bank with no local
retail distribution, we think this new deal has ingredients which
could be transformational for Bell potter.
04 opErating and Financial rEviEw
i am pleased to report a welcome return to
profitability with the Group recording a full year
after-tax profit of $6.8 million for Financial year
2013, a significant improvement on last year’s
$3.2 million after-tax loss.
top line revenues improved by 17% to $159 million while
overheads, excluding commissions paid to advisers, were down
7% ($5 million) largely due to the extensive cost reduction
exercise undertaken mid-way through 2012.
market conditions remained challenging throughout the year.
daily turnover was patchy, although an improvement on 2012,
and capital market flows stronger but slightly erratic.
the continuing low interest rate investment in australia and a
significantly lower australian dollar were market positives while
weakness in the resources sector and constant speculation
regarding the sustainability of chinese growth were negatives
which capped market gains. the australian all ordinaries index
rose 15% over the course of the year, primarily lead by the
banks, which reflected well in the values of client portfolios.
revenues in our retail division grew on average by 12%.
daily brokerage increased by 18% over the previous year in
line with improved investor confidence and better market
turnover. the value of Funds under advice, mainly sponsored
holdings, increased through a combination of new investment
and higher prices as did recurring revenue from our portfolio
administration service platform.
our wholesale division benefited from better volumes.
our sydney institutional desk, with the support of our internal
research team, has developed a reputation as a market leader in
the small / mid cap australian Equities space. our hong Kong
desk which has now been operating for a little more than 12
months is gaining good traction with its expanding asian client
base. once again london made a solid contribution, particularly
in relation to the distribution of new issues.
our Equity capital markets team had a much better year.
revenues were up 32% as a result of a higher number of
completed transactions particularly in the second half of the
year. the team has a strong pipeline of carry over transactions
for 2014.
our cash and margin lending business once again performed
well in a tough market. the loan book grew by 17% to $172
million despite investors remaining cautious. the cash book was
steady throughout and margins across the whole business were
maintained in a very competitive environment.
this business continues to be managed conservatively with an
average loan to value ratio (lvr) of 32%. no bad debts were
incurred during the period.
Bell Financial group currently owns 51.23% of Bell direct.
the business has grown strongly with revenues up 30% year
on year, 50,000 active trading accounts and $3.5 billion in
sponsored holdings. Bell direct was close to break-even over
the full year and is well positioned to move to sustainable future
profitability and contribute to the group’s bottom line.
BalanCe sheet
we have a strong balance sheet and cash position. the business
carries no debt other than the cash advance facility in our margin
lending business, Bell potter capital.
net assets at year end were $180 million (2012: $176 million),
net tangible assets were $47 million (2012: $44 million) and
cash and cash equivalents (excluding margin lending and client
cash) were $52 million (2012: $42 million).
overheads
group overheads excluding commission paid to advisers were
$71 million, down 7% or $5 million on 2012. as previously stated
the reduction was due mainly to the extensive review undertaken
mid-way through 2012. we continuously monitor our cost
structure to ensure it is appropriate as market conditions change.
outlook
it is difficult to make projections in our business. last year
i said our leverage to a positive change to investment sentiment
was high. that argument remains valid, if not more so, and 2013
was just a small indication of what we can achieve. Early signs
suggest that 2014 should be better again.
yours sincerely
alastair provan
managing director
Bell Financial group ltd
operatinG anD Financial review
05
revenue
($a m) 2009-2013
net proFit/(loss)
aFter taX
($a m) 2009-2013
equities eXeCution
revenue
($a m) 2009-2013
Funds under adviCe
($a B) 2009-2013
206.7
200.2
155.5
159.1
136.5
250
200
150
100
50
0
108.3
111.0
91.5
90.9
76.8
27.3
21.6
30
25
20
15
10
5
0
-5
7.6
6.8
-3.2
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
30
25
23.7
22.2
28.2
24.4
18.8
20
15
10
5
0
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
revenue
net profit / (loss) after tax
equities execution revenue
Funds under advice
■ 2013 group revenue was
■ consolidated full year
$159.1m, up 17% on 2012.
the increase was largely
due to an improvement in
both Equities Execution
revenues and Equity
capital markets revenues
as market sentiment
and investor confidence
improved on the prior year.
profit after tax was $6.8m,
a $10m turnaround on
the 2012 result. we are
confident the business
remains well positioned
to benefit from a positive
change to investment
sentiment.
■ 2013 Equities Execution
revenue was $90.9m, up
18% on the prior year.
the improvement was
largely driven by the
retail division as investors
tentatively re-entered the
market. wholesale also
improved on 2012 albeit
to a lesser extent.
■ Funds under advice
(Fua) includes sponsored
holdings, cash, margin
loans, portfolio
administration services
(pas) and superannuation.
■ Fua increased 16% over
2013 to $28.2b. the
increase was largely
attributable to movement
in market indices.
equity Capital
markets revenue
($a m) 2009-2013
marGin lendinG
& Cash revenue
($a m) 2009-2013
Bell direCt (online)
Gross revenue
($a m) 2009-2013
6.9
5.9
5.6
5.5
4.4
50.5
38.1
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
26.9
24.1
18.2
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
9.2
7.0
7.0
10
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
5.6
3.7
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
equities Capital markets
revenue
■ Ecm revenue was up 32%
on the prior year to $24.1m,
as a result of a higher
number of completed
transactions, particularly
in the second half.
Bell potter Capital margin
lending and Cash revenue
■ Bell potter capital, our
margin lending and cash
business, performed
solidly throughout 2013.
loan balances increased
17% to $172m, average
margins were maintained,
and there were no bad
debts of note.
Bell direct (online)
■ Full year Bell direct
consolidated revenues
and expenses were
included in the group’s
results for the first time.
while the overall Bell
direct result was around
breakeven, key metrics
including revenues, client
acquisition and sponsored
holdings all continue to
grow strongly.
■ 2013 revenue numbers
include a full 12-month
contribution from
Bell direct which was
consolidated from 28 may
2012 onward (additional
5-months contribution
due to consolidation –
approximately $3m).
06 dirEctors’ rEport For thE yEar EndEd 31 dEcEmbEr 2013
mr CraiG Coleman
Bcomm, university of western australia
mr coleman was appointed as a
director in July 2007 and has been a
non-executive director since october
2007. he is a member of the group
risk and audit committee and the
remuneration committee.
mr coleman is a senior advisor and
non-executive director of private
investment company, wyllie group pty
ltd. previously, he was managing director
and a non-executive director of home
Building society limited. prior to joining
home Building society, mr coleman held
a number of senior executive positions
and directorships with anZ, including
managing director – Banking products,
managing director – wealth management
and non-executive director of E*trade
australia limited.
mr Graham CuBBin
BEcon (hons), monash university
Fellow of the australian institute
of company directors
mr cubbin was appointed as a non-
executive director in september 2007 and
is an independent director. he is chairman
of the group risk and audit committee
and the remuneration committee.
mr cubbin was a senior Executive with
consolidated press holdings limited
(cph) from 1990 until september 2005,
including chief Financial officer for 13
years. prior to joining cph, he held senior
finance positions with a number of major
companies including capita Financial
group and Ford motor company.
mr cubbin has over 20 years’ experience
as a director and audit committee
member of public companies in australia
and the us.
other listed companies –
past three years
chairman, rubik Financial limited
(december 2006 – present)
non-executive director, amcom
telecommunications limited
(october 2008 – present)
chairman, lonestar resources limited
(July 2008 – present)
non-executive director, pulse health
limited (January 2010 – present)
other listed companies –
past three years
non-executive director, challenger
limited (January 2004 – present)
non-executive director, stw
communications group limited
(may 2008 – present)
non-executive director, white Energy
company limited
(February 2010 – present)
non-executive director, mcpherson’s
limited (september 2010 – present)
the directors of Bell Financial Group
limited (“Bell Financial” or “Company”)
present their report on the consolidated
entity (“Group”) consisting of Bell
Financial and its controlled entities and
associates at the end of or during the
year ended 31 december 2013.
direCtors
the directors of Bell Financial group
limited during the whole of the year and
up to the date of this report were:
■ mr c Bell
■ mr a provan
■ mr c coleman
■ mr g cubbin
■ mr B wilson
■ ms B shanahan.
particulars of the directors’
qualifications, experience, special
responsibilities and any directorships of
other listed companies are set out below.
mr Colin Bell
BEcon (hons), monash university
mr Bell is the Executive chairman of
Bell Financial and has responsibility
for the business development of the
company and all associated businesses
within the group. mr Bell founded Bell
commodities in 1970 after working with
the international Bank for reconstruction
and development in washington dc, usa.
mr alastair provan
mr provan is the managing director of
Bell Financial and is responsible for the
day-to-day management of all businesses
within the group. mr provan joined Bell
commodities in 1983 and held a number
of dealing and management roles prior to
becoming managing director in 1989.
mr provan is a member of the
remuneration committee.
Directors’ report For the year enDeD 31 DecemBer 2013
07
mr Brian wilson
mcomm (hons), auckland
mr wilson was appointed as a
non-executive director in october 2009.
mr wilson is also chairman of the
Foreign investment review Board,
deputy chancellor of university of
technology, sydney, and a member
of the payments system Board of the
reserve Bank of australia. he was
a member of the commonwealth
government review of australia’s
superannuation system and is currently
a member of the ato superannuation
reform steering committee.
mr wilson retired in 2009 as a managing
director of the global investment bank
lazard, after co-founding the firm in
australia in 2004 and was previously a
vice-chairman of citigroup australia and
its predecessor companies.
ms Brenda shanahan
B.comm, melbourne university
Fellow of the australian institute
of company directors
ms shanahan was appointed as a non-
executive director in June 2012 and is an
independent director. she is a member of
the group risk and audit committee and
the remuneration committee.
ms shanahan has served in senior
executive and Board roles in australia
and overseas, primarily in the finance
and stock broking industries, during a
career spanning more than 30 years.
ms shanahan was previously an Executive
director of Jm Financial group limited,
may mellor, Equitlink limited and
william m mercer. ms shanahan also
chairs the st vincent’s medical research
institute and the aikenhead centre for
medical discovery and is a director of the
Kimberley Foundation australia.
other listed companies –
past three years
non-executive director, clinuvel
pharmaceuticals limited
(February 2007– present)
non-executive director, challenger
limited (april 2011 – present)
prinCipal aCtivities
Bell Financial is an australian-based
provider of stockbroking, investment and
financial advisory services to private,
institutional and corporate clients.
operating across a network of 13 offices
in australia plus offices in london
and hong Kong, Bell Financial has
approximately 600 employees, including
more than 300 experienced advisers,
serving over 160,000 active clients with
funds under advice exceeding $28 billion.
Bell Financial has a 51.23% holding in
third party platform pty ltd (Bell direct),
an online stockbroking business.
operations
the group’s consolidated operating result
after income tax attributable to members
was a profit of $6.8 million (2012: $3.2
million loss). a review of the operations of
the group is set out in the operating and
Financial review section on pages 4 to 5.
option to aCquire shares in
Bell direCt
the company has a call option to
purchase all the shares in Bell direct it
does not own, taking its holding to 100%.
the exercise price of the call option is
to be satisfied by Bell Financial issuing
new shares and values all of Bell direct’s
existing share capital at $70 million.
the company has until 31 January 2015
to exercise the call option.
the company has granted a put option in
favour of certain Bell direct management
shareholders (who together held
approximately 4.5% of the shares in Bell
direct) permitting them to sell their Bell
direct shares to the company. the put
option values Bell direct at $35 million
and is exercisable at any time before
31 January 2015. in late January 2013,
two Bell direct shareholders exercised
their put options, which resulted in Bell
Financial’s ownership interest in Bell
direct increasing from 49.83% to 51.23%.
issue of shares under the call option is
subject to shareholder approval, which
the company will seek at the appropriate
time in accordance with the corporations
act and asx listing rule requirements
and prior to the exercise of the option.
Bell Financial is under no obligation to
exercise the call option and any decision
whether or not to exercise it will be
made by the company’s independent
non-executive directors at the relevant
time. as noted in the company’s previous
annual reports, the proposed issue of
Bell Financial shares to the grantors of
the call option will be subject to obtaining
relevant asic relief or shareholder
approval.
08 Directors’ report For the year enDeD 31 DecemBer 2013
matters suBsequent to the end
oF the FinanCial year
there has not arisen in the interval between
the end of the financial year and the date of
this report, any item, transaction or event of
a material and unusual nature likely, in the
opinion of the directors of the company, to
significantly affect:
■ the group’s operations in future
financial years, or
■ the results of those operations in
future financial years, or
■ the group’s state of affairs in future
Bell Financial’s alliance with citi replaces
the long-standing relationship the
company has had with uBs. the strategic
alliance agreement had an initial term
of three years from 12 december 2007
and was extended for a further three year
term to 12 december 2013, then again to
28 February 2014. as at the date of this
report, uBs owns 16.27% of the ordinary
shares in the company. on termination
of the strategic alliance agreement, all
of the company’s obligations to uBs
regarding shareholder restrictions, non-
dilution rights and distribution exclusivity
fall away.
Final dividend
on 25 February 2014, the directors
resolved to pay a fully franked final
dividend of 1.5 cents per share.
financial years,
other than:
Citi and Bell potter siGn mou
on 20 February 2014, Bell Financial
announced that it had signed a
memorandum of understanding (mou)
with citi. the arrangement will see Bell
potter’s retail and sophisticated investor
clients provided with access to citi’s
highly ranked global research platform
and securities products. the products
will include equity offerings, equity-linked
(hybrid instruments) and certain fixed
interest products. Bell potter’s retail
clients will be able to access a research
offering which combines citi’s resources
of highly rated research teams in EmEa,
asia and the americas with Bell potter’s
own predominantly small and medium
capitalized company research. the
distribution and research agreement is
being finalised and is intended to take
effect in the coming weeks.
Directors’ report For the year enDeD 31 DecemBer 2013
09
direCtors’ meetinGs
the number of meetings of the company’s Board of directors held during the year ended 31 december 2013, and the number of
meetings attended by each director, are set out below. Each director was a director for the full year.
direCtor
Board meetinGs
Group risk and audit
Committee meetinGs
remuneration
Committee meetinGs
colin Bell
alastair provan
graham cubbin
craig coleman
Brian wilson
Brenda shanahan
a
5
4
5
5
5
4
B
5
5
5
5
5
5
a
-
-
6
6
-
6
B
-
-
6
6
-
6
a
-
2
2
2
-
2
B
-
2
2
2
-
2
a – number of meetings attended B – number of meetings held during the year
direCtors’ interests
the relevant interests of each director in the shares and options over such instruments issued by the company as of the date of this
report is as follows:
Bell FinanCial Group ltd
direCt
indireCt
total
numBer oF
options
ordinary shares
name
colin Bell
alastair provan
graham cubbin
craig coleman
Brian wilson
Brenda shanahan
2,560,683
31,264,919
33,825,602
2,415,891
31,264,919
33,680,810
130,000
50,000
180,000
39,264
1,733,019
1,772,283
-
-
1,000,000
1,000,000
250,000
250,000
-
-
-
-
-
-
there were no changes to directors’ interests in the company’s shares between 31 december 2013 and the date of this report.
dividends
dividends paid or declared by the company to members during the financial year were as follows:
Cents per share
total amount $’000
Franked/ unFranked
date oF payment
deClared and paid durinG the year
Final 2012 ordinary
interim 2013 ordinary
-
1.0
-
2,596
-
-
Franked
25 september 2013
all dividends declared were fully franked at the tax rate of 30%. there were no dividends declared in 2012.
the directors have declared a final 2013 dividend (see previous page).
10 Directors’ report For the year enDeD 31 DecemBer 2013
Company seCretary
1.2 Chairman
cindy-Jane lee BEc/llB was appointed
as company secretary on 10 January
2014 and is also the company’s general
counsel. ms lee has over 13 years’
experience in corporate and financial
services law and has previously worked in
london and singapore.
ms lee replaced dean davenport BBus,
chief Financial officer, who was the
company secretary from 18 July 2013
to 10 January 2014. mr davenport is a
chartered accountant with over 20 years
financial services industry experience.
paul vine was company secretary from
2007 to 19 July 2013.
Corporate GovernanCe
Bell Financial recognises the importance
of good corporate governance practices.
this section outlines key aspects of
its corporate governance policies and
frameworks.
Bell Financial developed its corporate
governance framework by reference to
the asx corporate governance council’s
corporate governance principles
and recommendations with 2010
amendments (“asx recommendations”).
the asx recommendations are guidelines
of practices designed to optimise
corporate performance and accountability.
having regard to the structure, size and
nature of operations of Bell Financial,
the Board considers that certain asx
recommendations are not appropriate
to its particular circumstances at
present. departures from the asx
recommendations are identified below.
1.0 Board oF direCtors
1.1 Composition of the Board
the members of the Board and their
experience and qualifications were set out
on pages 6 to 7.
the chairman of the Board is not an
independent director. this represents a
departure from the asx recommendations.
colin Bell serves as the Executive
chairman. the Board considers that this
is in the best interests of Bell Financial
given his experience, expertise and
understanding of the business. alastair
provan, the managing director, has the
primary responsibility for the discharge of
the chief executive function including the
day-to-day management of Bell Financial.
in this way, the Executive chairman is
not distracted in performing the role of
chairman effectively.
1.3 directors’ independence
an independent director is a non-
executive director who is not a member
of management and who is free of any
business or other relationship that
could materially interfere with, or could
reasonably be perceived to materially
interfere with, the independent exercise
of their judgement. the Board charter
contains the principles used by the Board
in assessing independence.
during 2013, there were four non-
executive directors on the Board -
graham cubbin, craig coleman, Brian
wilson, and Brenda shanahan. mr cubbin
and ms shanahan are independent
non-executive directors. the Board did
not consider that mr coleman was an
“independent” director in 2013 as he
provided consultancy services to Bell
Financial during the year. the Board
did not consider that mr wilson was
an “independent” director in 2013 as
he provided consultancy services to
Bell Financial in 2012. their status as
independent directors may change over
time and this will be disclosed to the
market in a timely manner. as at the
date of this report the Board does not
have a majority of independent directors,
however it has a majority of non-
executive directors.
the Board considers that it has the
appropriate balance of experience,
expertise and independence to enable it
to discharge its functions effectively.
1.4 independent professional advice
directors are, after consultation with
the chairman, able to seek independent
professional advice at the company’s
expense. where appropriate, the advice
may be made available to the Board.
1.5 director education
the group has a formal process to educate
new directors about the nature of the
business, current issues, the corporate
strategy, and the expectations of the group
concerning performance of directors.
directors also have the opportunity to
meet with management to gain a better
understanding of business operations.
directors are given access to continuing
education opportunities to update and
enhance their skills and knowledge.
2.0 Board responsiBilities
the Board is responsible for the overall
corporate governance of Bell Financial,
which includes effective oversight of
management. the Board has adopted
a Board charter, a copy of which is
available on Bell Financial’s website,
www.bellfg.com.au/corporategovernance.
aspx. the Board charter contains a
description of the specific responsibilities
reserved to the Board.
the Board charter also describes the
nature of matters delegated to the senior
executives, and includes a description
of the respective roles of the Executive
chairman and the managing director.
this description is designed to clearly
identify the division of responsibility at the
senior executive level of Bell Financial.
the managing director has authority to
sub-delegate to the senior executive team.
whilst the appointment of an Executive
chairman represents a departure from
the asx recommendations, the Board is
satisfied that the division of responsibility
is clearly articulated and ensures
appropriate accountability.
Directors’ report For the year enDeD 31 DecemBer 2013
11
the Board is responsible for monitoring
the senior executive team’s performance.
as part of the delegation of authority
to manage the day-to-day affairs of
the company, the managing director
carries out a performance evaluation
for senior executives regularly, against
appropriate performance objectives and
indicators. a performance evaluation for
senior executives was carried out by the
managing director in 2013 in accordance
with that process.
3.0 Board Committees
the Board charter contemplates that the
Board may delegate certain functions to
Board committees to assist the Board in
the discharge of its oversight role. these
committees are required to consider
particular issues in detail and then report
back to and advise the Board. the Board
has established two standing committees,
the functions of which are discussed
below. a copy of the Board committee
charters are also available on Bell
Financial’s website, www.bellfg.com.au/
corporategovernance.aspx.
3.1 Group risk and audit Committee
the group risk and audit committee
(grac) assists the Board to carry out
its oversight role in relation to risk
management, accounting, auditing
and financial reporting. the core
responsibilities of the grac include
reviewing and, where required, providing
recommendations to the Board on:
■ the effectiveness of Bell Financial’s
risk management and internal
control systems,
■ external financial reporting and
financial statements,
■ the discharge of the internal audit
function, and
■ matters relating to the appointment,
independence and performance of
the external auditor, and the rotation
of the external auditor.
the grac charter stipulates that the
chair of the committee must be an
independent non-executive director, who
is not the chairman of the Board. the
grac charter also stipulates that the
committee must be comprised of only
non-executive directors, a majority of
independent directors and have at least
three members.
during 2013, the members of the grac
were mr cubbin (chairman), mr coleman,
and ms shanahan. Each director was a
grac member for the full year. a copy
of the grac charter is available on Bell
Financial’s website, www.bellfg.com.au/
corporategovernance.aspx.
3.2 remuneration committee
the remuneration committee assists
and advises the Board on remuneration
matters. the role of the remuneration
committee is to develop, review and
make recommendations to the Board
on the remuneration framework for
the non-executive directors, executive
directors, other key management
personnel and senior executives. this
includes recommendations in relation
to incentive schemes and equity based
plans where appropriate. an overview of
Bell Financial’s remuneration policy and
framework is contained in section 2 of the
remuneration report.
the members of the remuneration
committee during 2013 were mr cubbin
(chairman), mr coleman, mr provan,
and ms shanahan. Each director was
a committee member for the full year.
the composition of the remuneration
committee represents a departure from
the asx recommendations that propose
that a majority of members should
be independent directors. however,
the Board is satisfied that, given the
majority of non-executive directors,
the remuneration committee has the
appropriate balance of experience,
expertise and independence to enable it
to discharge its functions effectively.
a copy of the remuneration committee
charter is available on Bell Financial’s
website, www.bellfg.com.au/
corporategovernance.aspx.
4.0 Board nominations
and renewal
the company does not have a nominations
committee and this is a departure from
the asx recommendations. the Board
does not consider that delegating the
Board selection and appointment practices
of Bell Financial to a separate committee
would enhance efficiency. instead, the
Board has reserved to itself relevant
responsibilities, including appointing
and removing the managing director,
developing and approving succession plans
for the Board and key senior executives,
and overseeing that membership of the
Board has the mix of experience, skills and
diversity appropriate for Bell Financial’s
needs, as identified in the Board charter.
a performance evaluation in accordance
with the Board charter was carried out in
2013 in relation to the directors and the
two Board committees.
there must be an election of directors
at each annual general meeting.
the constitution of the company provides,
amongst other things, for a process of
retirement of directors by rotation (which
will occur for each director approximately
every three years except for the managing
director, alastair provan). directors who
retire from office are eligible to stand for
re-election.
5.0 Company poliCies
5.1 ongoing disclosure
with a view to ensuring that investors
are informed of all major developments
affecting Bell Financial and its
businesses, the Board has adopted
policies designed to ensure that Bell
Financial meets the continuous disclosure
obligations imposed by the asx listing
rules and the corporations act.
information is communicated to
shareholders through asx announcements,
annual reports and half-yearly updates
which are accessible on Bell Financial’s
website, www.bellfg.com.au.
a copy of the disclosure and
communications policy and guidelines is
available on Bell Financial’s website,
www.bellfg.com.au/corporategovernance.
aspx.
12 Directors’ report For the year enDeD 31 DecemBer 2013
5.2 securities trading guidelines
Bell Financial has adopted a trading
policy that applies to directors, executives
and employees of Bell Financial.
the trading policy explains the type of
conduct in relation to dealings in the
company’s securities that is prohibited
under the corporations act, and
establishes procedures in relation to
directors, executives and employees
dealing in securities of the company.
under the trading policy, directors and
designated employees may not deal in
securities of the company during the
following “black-out periods” (subject to
limited exceptions):
■ from the end of the company’s
financial year (31 december) until
release of its full year results in
February; and
■ from the end of the company’s half-
year (30 June) until release of its
half-year results in august.
other “black-out periods” may be
declared from time to time. the
policy contains an approval process
to be followed by directors and other
designated employees if they propose to
deal in the company’s securities. a copy
of the trading policy is available on Bell
Financial’s website, www.bellfg.com.au/
corporategovernance.aspx.
5.3 Code of conduct
Bell Financial has developed a code
of conduct (code), which applies to all
directors, officers, employees, contractors,
consultants and associates. Bell Financial
is committed to honesty and integrity in
all its dealings, as well as ensuring the
highest quality of service is provided to
customers and clients at all times. the
code sets out the ethical standards, values
and policies of the company. it provides a
framework to guide compliance with legal
and other obligations to stakeholders,
commitment to which the Board believes
will maintain the confidence of the
company’s stakeholders.
the code states that all potential or
actual conflicts of interest must be
avoided or disclosed. directors must keep
the Board advised, on an ongoing basis,
of any interest that could potentially
conflict with those of the company. where
the Board believes that a significant
conflict exists for a director on a Board
matter, the director concerned will not
receive the relevant Board papers and
must not be present at the meeting while
the item is considered. details of the
director related party transactions with
the company and the group are set out in
note 33 of the financial statements.
5.4 diversity
considerable diversity exists throughout
the Bell Financial group, in terms of age,
culture and gender. the company values
diversity in the workplace and is committed
to employing people on the basis of the
“best fit” for the job, based on relative ability,
performance and potential. the company
departs from the asx recommendations
in that it does not disclose measurable
objectives around gender diversity, nor
does it disclose the proportion of women
employees at organisation, senior executive
and Board level.
Bell Financial has a diversity policy,
which is available on the company’s
website, www.bellfg.com.au/
corporategovernance.aspx.
5.5 risk assessment and management
the Board understands that the
management of risk is a continuous
process and an integral part of sound
business management and corporate
governance. the group risk and
audit committee (grac) plays a key
role in assisting the Board with its
responsibilities relating to accounting,
internal control systems, reporting
practices, risk management and
monitoring the independence of the
company’s external auditors.
the company has implemented a risk
management policy and Framework
based on australian/new Zealand
standard as/nZ iso 3100:2009 Risk
Management Standard. a description of the
risk management policy Framework is
available on Bell Financial’s website, www.
bellfg.com.au/corporategovernance.aspx.
the grac reviewed and approved the
company’s risk management policy
and its risk management plan in 2013.
the grac reported to the company’s
Board on these matters and the Board
is satisfied that the company’s risk
management and internal control system
is appropriate.
the group’s principal financial
instruments comprise listed securities,
derivatives, term deposits and cash.
the main risks arising from the group’s
financial instruments are market risk,
credit risk and liquidity risk. these are
examined in more detail in note 3 of the
financial statements.
5.6 Financial reporting
the managing director and chief Financial
officer have declared in writing to the
Board that the declaration provided to the
Board in accordance with section 295a of
the corporations act is founded on a sound
system of risk management and internal
control and that the system is operating
effectively in all material respects in
relation to financial reporting risks.
5.7 external auditors
the company policy is to appoint external
auditors who demonstrate quality and
independence. the performance of the
auditor is reviewed annually. Kpmg is Bell
Financial’s external auditor.
an analysis of fees paid to the external
auditor is provided in note 37 of the
financial statements.
the external auditor will attend the annual
general meeting and be available to
answer shareholder questions about the
conduct of the audit and the preparation
and content of the auditor’s report.
Directors’ report For the year enDeD 31 DecemBer 2013
13
the company may decide to engage the auditor on assignments additional to their statutory audit duties where the auditor’s
expertise in relation to the group is important. the Board has considered the position and, in accordance with the advice from the
group audit and risk committee (grac), is satisfied that the provision of the non-audit services is compatible with the general
standard of independence for auditors outlined by the corporations act. the directors are satisfied that the auditor’s independence
is not compromised in relation to non-audit services for the following reasons:
■ all non-audit services have been reviewed by the grac to ensure they do not impact the impartiality and objectivity of the auditor,
■ none of the services undermine the general principles relating to auditor independence as set out in APES 110 Code of ethics for
professional accountants.
5.8 internal audit
the internal auditors assist the grac in ensuring compliance with internal controls and risk management programs by regularly
reviewing the effectiveness of the company’s internal controls and systems. the grac is responsible for approving the program of
internal audit visits to be conducted each financial year and for the scope of the work to be performed. the grac is responsible for
recommending to the Board the appointment and dismissal of the internal audit and risk manager.
6.0 asX Corporate GovernanCe reCommendations
the asx listing rules require listed entities to include in their annual report a statement disclosing the extent to which they have
followed the recommendations set out by the asx corporate governance council during the reporting period, identifying the
recommendations that have not been followed and giving reasons for not following them.
asX Corporate GovernanCe reCommendation
reFerenCe
Comply
prinCiple 1:
lay solid Foundations For manaGement and oversiGht
1.1
1.2
1.3
Establish the functions reserved to the Board and those delegated to senior
executives and disclose those functions.
disclose the process for evaluating the performance of senior executives.
provide the information indicated in the guide to reporting on principle 1.
prinCiple 2:
struCture the Board to add value
2.1
2.2
2.3
2.4
2.5
2.6
a majority of the Board should be independent directors.
the chair should be an independent director.
the roles of chair and chief Executive officer should not be exercised by the same individual.
the Board should establish a nomination committee.
disclose the process for evaluating the performance of the Board, committees and
individual directors.
provide the information indicated in the guide to reporting on principle 2.
prinCiple 3:
promote ethiCal and responsiBle deCision makinG
Establish a code of conduct and disclose the code or a summary of the code as to:
■ the practices necessary to maintain confidence in the company’s integrity
■ the practices necessary to take into account the company’s legal obligations and
the reasonable expectations of stakeholders
■ the responsibility and accountability of individuals for reporting and investigating
reports of unethical practices.
Establish a policy concerning diversity and disclose the policy or a summary of that
policy. the policy should include requirements for the Board to establish measurable
objectives for achieving gender diversity for the Board to assess annually both the
objectives and progress for achieving them.
disclose in each annual report the measurable objectives for achieving gender
diversity set by the Board in accordance with the diversity policy and progress towards
achieving them.
disclose in each annual report the proportion of women employees in the whole
organisation, women in senior executive positions and women on the Board.
3.1
3.2
3.3
3.4
3.5
2
2
2
1.3
1.2
1.2
4
4
1
5.3
5.4
3
3
3
non-comply
non-comply
3
non-comply
3
3
3
3
non-comply
non-comply
provide the information indicated in the guide to reporting on principle 3.
5.4
3
14 Directors’ report For the year enDeD 31 DecemBer 2013
asX Corporate GovernanCe reCommendation
reFerenCe
Comply
prinCiple 4:
saFeGuard inteGrity in FinanCial reportinG
4.1
4.2
4.3
4.4
the Board should establish an audit committee.
the audit committee should be structured so that it:
■ consists of only non-executive directors
■ consists of a majority of independent directors
■ is chaired by an independent chair, who is not chair of the Board
■ has at least three members.
the audit committee should have a formal charter.
provide the information indicated in the guide to reporting on principle 4.
prinCiple 5:
make timely and BalanCed disClosure
5.1
5.2
Establish written policies designed to ensure compliance with asx listing rules
disclosure requirements and to ensure accountability at a senior executive level for
that compliance and disclose those policies or a summary of those policies.
provide the information indicated in the guide to reporting on principle 5.
prinCiple 6:
respeCt the riGhts oF shareholders
6.1
6.2
design a communications policy for promoting effective communication with
shareholders and encouraging their participation at general meetings and disclose
the policy or a summary of that policy.
provide the information indicated in the guide to reporting on principle 6.
prinCiple 7:
reCoGnise and manaGe risk
7.1
7.2
7.3
Establish policies for the oversight and management of material business risks and
disclose a summary of those policies.
the Board should require management to design and implement the risk
management and internal control system to manage the company’s material
business risks and report to it on whether those risks are being managed effectively.
the Board should disclose that management has reported to it as to the effectiveness
of the company’s management of its material business risks.
the Board should disclose whether it has received assurance from the chief
Executive officer (or equivalent) and the chief Financial officer (or equivalent) that
the declaration provided in accordance with section 295a of the corporations act
is founded on a sound system of risk management and internal control and that
the system is operating efficiently in all material respects in relation to financial
reporting risks.
3.1
3.1
3.1
3.1
5.1
5.1
5.1
5.1
5.5
5.5
5.6
7.4
provide the information indicated in the guide to reporting on principle 7.
5.5, 5.6
prinCiple 8:
remunerate Fairly and responsiBility
8.1
8.2
8.3
8.4
the Board should establish a remuneration committee.
the remuneration committee should be structured so that it:
■ consists of a majority of independent directors
■ is chaired by an independent director
■ has at least 3 members.
clearly distinguish the structure of non-executive directors’ remuneration
from that of executive directors and senior executives.
provide the information indicated in the guide to reporting on principle 8.
3.2
3.2
3.2
3.2
3.2,
remuneration
report
3.2,
remuneration
report
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
non-comply
3
3
3
3
Directors’ report For the year enDeD 31 DecemBer 2013
15
remuneration report (audited)
1. key management personnel (kmp)
Kmp include each of the directors, both non-executive and executive, and those executives who have authority and responsibility for
planning, directing and controlling the activities of Bell Financial group. in this report, “Executive Kmp” refers to Kmp other than
non-executive directors.
the Kmp for 2013 are set out in the Kmp remuneration table in section 8.5 below.
2. overview of remuneration policy and framework
Bell Financial group remunerates Executive Kmp and other executives, management and advisers by one or more of fixed salary,
commission entitlements and other short-term and long-term incentives. non-executive directors receive a fixed fee and statutory
superannuation only for their role on the Board.
in considering the group’s performance and benefits for shareholder wealth, the remuneration committee and the Board have
regard to the following financial indicators in respect of the current financial year and previous financial years.
net profit / (loss) after tax
share price at year end
dividends declared
2009
$’000
2010
$’000
$27,288
$21,569
$1.17
$0.97
$19,377
$16,162
2011
$’000
$7,639
$0.605
$7,649
2012
$’000
($3,189)
$0.46
-
2013
$’000
$6,811
$0.70
$2,596
the company has established two equity-based plans to assist in the attraction, retention and motivation of Executive Kmp,
management and employees of the company. the long term incentive plan and the Employee share acquisition (tax exempt) plan.
Each plan contains customary and standard terms for dealing with the administration of an employee share plan, and the termination
and suspension of the plan. participants in the plans must not enter into a transaction or arrangement or otherwise deal in financial
products which operate to limit the economic risk of the unvested Bell Financial group securities issued under the plans.
3. Fixed compensation
Fixed compensation consists of base compensation as well as employer contributions to superannuation funds. compensation
levels are reviewed annually through a process that considers individual performance and that of the overall group.
4. Commission
commission entitlements are determined by the Board from time to time and aim to align the remuneration of Executive Kmp and
advisers with the company’s performance. in general, certain executives and advisers are paid a commission based on revenue
generated by the individual during the year. this creates a strong incentive for key executives and advisers to maximise the
company’s revenues and performance.
5. performance linked compensation
performance linked compensation includes both short-term and long-term incentives and is designed to reward executive directors and
Executive Kmp for meeting or exceeding their financial and individual objectives. the short-term incentive is an ‘at risk’ bonus provided
in the form of cash, while the long-term incentive is provided as options or performance rights over ordinary shares of the company.
16 Directors’ report For the year enDeD 31 DecemBer 2013
8.2 executives
all key executives are permanent
employees of Bell Financial group. Each
executive has an employment contract
with no fixed end date. any executive
may resign from their position by giving
four weeks’ written notice. the company
may terminate an employment contract
by providing written notice and making
payment in lieu of notice in accordance
with the company’s termination
policies. the company may terminate
an employment contract at any time for
serious misconduct.
Eligible persons participating may be
granted options or performance rights
on the terms and conditions in the
ltip rules and as determined by the
Board from time to time. an option or
performance right is a right, subject to
the satisfaction of the applicable vesting
conditions and exercise conditions, to
subscribe for a share in the company.
if persons become entitled to participate
in the ltip and their participation
requires approval under chapter 10 of the
asx listing rules, they will not participate
in the ltip until that shareholder approval
is received.
8. service agreements
8.1 executive Chairman and
managing director
Bell Financial group entered into service
agreements with its Executive chairman,
colin Bell, and its managing director,
alastair provan, effective from listing
in december 2007. these agreements
set out the terms of each appointment,
including responsibilities, duties, rights
and remuneration.
a summary of the remuneration packages
including benefits under the short-term
and long-term incentive plans for both
mr Bell and mr provan is set out in the
Kmp remuneration table in section 8.5.
Bell Financial group may terminate either
service agreement on 12 months’ notice, or
immediately for cause. if either agreement
is terminated on 12 months’ notice, Bell
Financial group has agreed to vest early
any unvested options under the ltip and
to allow their early exercise. mr Bell and
mr provan may terminate their respective
service agreements on six months’ notice.
mr Bell and mr provan have entered
into non-competition covenants with
Bell Financial group which operate for
six months from termination of their
respective service agreements.
remuneration report (audited)
cont.
6. short-term incentive bonus
the company may pay Executive Kmp
and other executives a short-term
incentive (sti) annually. the company’s
remuneration committee is responsible
for determining who is eligible to
participate in sti arrangements, as well
as the structure of those arrangements.
there are two types of sti arrangements,
being:
■ the sti payable to executives who
are not remunerated by reference to
commission, which is a discretionary
annual cash bonus determined
based on the company’s financial
performance during the year, key
performance indicators, industry
competitive measures and individual
performance over the period;
■ the sti payable to the Executive
chairman and the managing director,
which is a discretionary annual cash
bonus, up to three times annual
salary, determined based on the
company’s financial performance
during the year, key performance
indicators as well as individual
performance over the period.
these sti arrangements aim to ensure
that executive remuneration is aligned
with the company’s financial performance
and growth.
7. long-term incentive plan (ltip)
the ltip is part of the company’s
remuneration strategy and is designed
to align the interests of the company’s
Executive Kmp, other executives
and advisers with the interests of
shareholders to assist the company in
the attraction, motivation and retention
of Executive Kmp, other executives
and advisers. in particular, the ltip is
designed to provide relevant Executive
Kmp, other executives and advisers with
an incentive for future performance, with
conditions for the vesting and exercise of
the options or performance rights under
the ltip, therefore encouraging them to
remain with the company and contribute
to its future performance.
Directors’ report For the year enDeD 31 DecemBer 2013
17
8.3 non-executive directors
on appointment to the Board, all the non-executive directors (mr coleman, mr cubbin, mr wilson, and ms shanahan) were provided
with a letter of appointment setting out the terms, including responsibilities, duties, rights and remuneration, relevant to the office
of director. a summary of the annual remuneration package for those directors is in the following section of this report.
name
craig coleman
Brian wilson
graham cubbin
Brenda shanahan
a) Craig Coleman
direCtors’ Fees
superannuation
$
91,638
91,638
91,638
91,638
$
8,362
8,362
8,362
8,362
total
$
100,000
100,000
100,000
100,000
during 2013, mr coleman provided consultancy services to Bell Financial and was paid $50,000 (2012: $165,000) in relation to those
services. mr coleman is the chairman of Bell direct.
B) Brian wilson
during 2013, mr wilson did not provide consultancy services to Bell Financial. (in 2012, mr wilson provided consultancy services to
Bell Financial and was paid $100,000 in relation to those services.)
18 Directors’ report For the year enDeD 31 DecemBer 2013
remuneration report (audited) cont.
8.4 kmp remuneration
details of the remuneration of each Kmp are tabled below.
direCtors
eXeCutive direCtors
colin Bell, Executive chairman1
alastair provan, managing director1
non-eXeCutive direCtors
graham cubbin
craig coleman
Brian wilson
malcolm spry3
Brenda shanahan3
total compensation: directors (consolidated)
eXeCutives
lewis Bell, head of compliance
andrew Bell, Executive director of Bell potter securities
dean davenport, chief Financial officer
rowan Fell, director – investment services
paul vine, general counsel and company secretary4
total compensation: executives (consolidated)
short-term
salary &
Fees
sti Cash
Bonus
non-monetary
BeneFits
$
$
$
2013
2012
2013
2012
2013
2012
2013
2012
2013
2012
2013
2012
2013
2012
2013
2012
2013
2012
2013
2012
2013
2012
2013
2012
2013
2012
2013
2012
599,190
582,345
527,153
528,153
91,638
91,743
141,638
256,743
91,638
183,935
-
55,810
91,638
52,576
1,542,895
1,751,305
359,502
352,002
566,999
328,047
282,878
291,765
312,873
313,877
141,644
233,877
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
100,000
50,000
110,000
55,000
-
-
1,663,896
1,519,568
210,000
105,000
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
total
$
599,190
582,345
527,153
528,153
91,638
91,743
141,638
256,743
91,638
183,935
-
55,810
91,638
52,576
1,542,895
1,751,305
359,502
352,002
566,999
328,047
382,878
341,765
422,873
368,877
141,644
233,877
1,873,896
1,624,568
1. colin Bell and alastair provan volunteered to forego any discretionary annual cash bonus in 2012 and 2013.
2. voluntary super contributions above the minimum legislative requirements are classified as post-employment benefits.
3. malcolm spry resigned on 5 June 2012. Brenda shanahan was appointed on 5 June 2012.
4. paul vine resigned with effect from 19 July 2013.
superannuation
other lonG
termination
total amortisation
post-
employment
BeneFits2
$
term
$
share-Based
payments
proportion oF
remuneration
value oF
options as
perFormanCe
proportion oF
BeneFits2
value oF lti options
total
related
remuneration
$
$
$
20,810
37,655
17,122
16,123
8,362
8,257
8,362
8,257
8,362
16,065
-
5,023
8,362
4,732
71,380
96,112
30,000
37,500
41,863
50,169
17,122
8,235
17,122
16,123
9,456
16,123
115,653
128,150
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
620,000
620,000
544,275
544,276
100,000
100,000
150,000
265,000
100,000
200,000
-
60,833
100,000
57,308
389,502
389,502
608,862
378,216
419,567
350,000
449,779
385,000
151,100
250,000
1,614,275
1,847,417
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
19,567
9,784
29,351
2,018,810
1,752,718
%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
24%
14%
24%
14%
0%
0%
10%
6%
%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
5%
0%
2%
0%
0%
0%
1%
0%
short-term
salary &
sti Cash
non-monetary
Bonus
BeneFits
total
$
$
$
remuneration report (audited) cont.
8.4 kmp remuneration
details of the remuneration of each Kmp are tabled below.
direCtors
eXeCutive direCtors
colin Bell, Executive chairman1
alastair provan, managing director1
non-eXeCutive direCtors
graham cubbin
craig coleman
Brian wilson
malcolm spry3
Brenda shanahan3
total compensation: directors (consolidated)
eXeCutives
lewis Bell, head of compliance
andrew Bell, Executive director of Bell potter securities
dean davenport, chief Financial officer
rowan Fell, director – investment services
paul vine, general counsel and company secretary4
total compensation: executives (consolidated)
Fees
$
599,190
582,345
527,153
528,153
91,638
91,743
141,638
256,743
91,638
183,935
-
55,810
91,638
52,576
359,502
352,002
566,999
328,047
282,878
291,765
312,873
313,877
141,644
233,877
1,542,895
1,751,305
2013
2012
2013
2012
2013
2012
2013
2012
2013
2012
2013
2012
2013
2012
2013
2012
2013
2012
2013
2012
2013
2012
2013
2012
2013
2012
2013
2012
100,000
50,000
110,000
55,000
1,663,896
1,519,568
210,000
105,000
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
599,190
582,345
527,153
528,153
91,638
91,743
141,638
256,743
91,638
183,935
-
55,810
91,638
52,576
1,542,895
1,751,305
359,502
352,002
566,999
328,047
382,878
341,765
422,873
368,877
141,644
233,877
1,873,896
1,624,568
1. colin Bell and alastair provan volunteered to forego any discretionary annual cash bonus in 2012 and 2013.
2. voluntary super contributions above the minimum legislative requirements are classified as post-employment benefits.
3. malcolm spry resigned on 5 June 2012. Brenda shanahan was appointed on 5 June 2012.
4. paul vine resigned with effect from 19 July 2013.
Directors’ report For the year enDeD 31 DecemBer 2013
19
post-
employment
share-Based
payments
superannuation
BeneFits2
other lonG
term
termination
BeneFits2
total amortisation
value oF lti options
$
$
$
20,810
37,655
17,122
16,123
8,362
8,257
8,362
8,257
8,362
16,065
-
5,023
8,362
4,732
71,380
96,112
30,000
37,500
41,863
50,169
17,122
8,235
17,122
16,123
9,456
16,123
115,653
128,150
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
proportion oF
remuneration
perFormanCe
related
value oF
options as
proportion oF
remuneration
%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
24%
14%
24%
14%
0%
0%
10%
6%
%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
0%
5%
0%
2%
0%
0%
0%
1%
0%
$
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
19,567
-
9,784
-
-
-
total
$
620,000
620,000
544,275
544,276
100,000
100,000
150,000
265,000
100,000
200,000
-
60,833
100,000
57,308
1,614,275
1,847,417
389,502
389,502
608,862
378,216
419,567
350,000
449,779
385,000
151,100
250,000
29,351
2,018,810
-
1,752,718
20 Directors’ report For the year enDeD 31 DecemBer 2013
remuneration report (audited) cont.
8.5 kmp remuneration (Group)
notes on Kmp remuneration table
a)
in relation to the Executive Kmp, the short-term incentive bonus is for performance during the financial year ended
31 december 2013 using the criteria set out in section 6 of the remuneration report.
B) options were issued to dean davenport and rowan Fell in may 2013. the fair value of the options is calculated at the date of
grant using an option-pricing model and allocated to each reporting period evenly over the period from grant date to vesting
date. the value disclosed is the portion of the fair value of the options recognised in this reporting period. in valuing the options,
market conditions have been taken into account.
the following factors and assumptions were used in determining the fair value of options on grant date:
Grant date
option
eXerCise
date
Fair value
per option
eXerCise
priCe
priCe oF
shares on
Grant date
eXpeCted
volatility
risk Free
interest
rate
dividend
yield
28 may 13
28 may 20161
$0.08386
$0.802
$0.55
45.76%
2.62%
2.0%
1. options can be exercised for a period of up to 12 months from exercise date.
2. represents exercise price at grant.
Equity instruments
all options refer to options over ordinary shares of Bell Financial, which are exercisable on a one-for-one basis under the lti plan.
9. options granted as compensation
details on options over ordinary shares in the company that were granted as compensation to each Kmp in 2013 and details on
options that were vested during the reporting period are outlined below.
numBer
oF options
Granted
durinG 2013
Fair value
per option at
Grant date ($)
Grant date
eXerCise priCe
per option ($)
eXpiry date
numBer
oF options
vested durinG
2013
eXeCutive direCtors
colin Bell
alastair provan
non-eXeCutive direCtors
graham cubbin
Brenda shanahan
Brian wilson
craig coleman
eXeCutives
andrew Bell
lewis Bell
dean davenport
rowan Fell
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
400,000
200,000
28 may 2013
28 may 2013
$0.08386
$0.08386
$0.80
$0.80
28 may 2017
28 may 2017
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
the options were granted at no cost to the recipient. the options vest on 28 may 2016 and are exercisable for a period of 12 months
after that date, provided that the Kmp remains employed as an executive or a director of the company as at that date.
Directors’ report For the year enDeD 31 DecemBer 2013
21
9.1 modification of terms of equity-settled share-based payment transactions
no terms of equity settled share based payment transactions (including options granted to executives) have been altered or
modified by the issuing entity during the reporting period.
9.2 exercise of options granted as compensation
Following the vesting date on the accelerated vesting of an option, the vested option may be exercised by the executive subject to any
exercise conditions and the payment of the exercise price (if any).
no options granted as compensation were exercised during the period.
9.3 analysis of options granted as compensation
details of vesting profile of the options granted as remuneration to each Kmp are detailed below.
eXeCutive direCtors
colin Bell
alastair provan
non-eXeCutive direCtors
graham cubbin
Brenda shanahan
Brian wilson
craig coleman
eXeCutives
lewis Bell
andrew Bell
dean davenport
rowan Fell
options Granted
numBer
date
% vested in
year
FinanCial
years in whiCh
Grant vests
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
400,000
200,000
28 may 13
28 may 13
0%
0%
28 may 2016
28 may 2016
9.4 analysis of movements in options
there was no movement in options during the year.
9.5 unissued shares under options
at the date of this report unissued ordinary shares of the company granted to directors and employees under option are:
eXpiry date
28 may 2017
all options expire on the earlier of termination date or expiry date.
eXerCise priCe
numBer oF
options
$0.80
23,000,000
22 Directors’ report For the year enDeD 31 DecemBer 2013
likely developments
Further details of likely developments
in the operations of the group and its
prospects in future financial years are
contained in the chairman’s report and
the operating and Financial review set
out on pages 2 to 5. in the opinion of
the directors, disclosure of any further
information would be likely to result in
unreasonable prejudice to the group.
lead auditor’s independence declaration
the lead auditor’s independence
declaration is set out on page 23 and
forms part of the directors’ report for the
financial year ended 31 december 2013.
rounding of amounts
the company is of a kind referred to in
asic class order 98/100 dated 10 January
1998 and in accordance with that class
order, amounts in the financial report and
directors’ report have been rounded off
to the nearest thousand dollars, unless
otherwise stated.
signed in accordance with a resolution of
the directors.
Colin Bell
Executive chairman
25 February 2014
indemniFiCation and
insuranCe oF direCtors
indemnification
the company has agreed to indemnify
the directors against all liabilities to
another person (other than the company
or a related entity) that may arise from
their position as directors of the company
or its controlled entities, except where the
liability arises out of conduct including
a lack of good faith.
Except for the above, neither the
company nor its controlled entities has
indemnified any person who is or has
been an officer or auditor of the company
or its controlled entities.
insurance premiums
since the end of the previous financial
year the company has paid a premium
for an insurance policy for the benefit of
the directors, officers, secretaries and
senior executives of the company. in
accordance with commercial practice, the
policy prohibits disclosure of the nature of
insurance or amount of the premium.
environmental regulation
the operations of the group are not
subject to any particular and significant
environmental regulation under a law of
the commonwealth of a state or territory.
to the best of the company’s knowledge
no member of the group has incurred any
material environmental liability during
the year.
non-audit services
the company may decide to engage the
auditor on assignments additional to their
statutory audit duties where the auditor’s
expertise with the group is important.
the provision of these services and the
auditor’s independence are discussed at
section 5.7.
details of the amounts paid to the auditor
of the company, Kpmg, and its related
practices for audit and non-audit services
provided during the year are set in note 38
of the financial statements.
lEad auditor’s indEpEndEncE dEclaration
23
lead auditor’s independence declaration under section 307c of the Corporations Act 2001
to: the directors of Bell Financial group limited
i declare that, to the best of my knowledge and belief, in relation to the audit for the financial year ended
31 december 2013, there have been:
i) no contraventions of the auditor independence requirements as set out in the Corporations Act 2001 in
relation to the audit; and
ii) no contraventions of any applicable code of professional conduct in relation to the audit.
Kpmg
dean m waters
partner
melbourne
25 February 2014
KpmG, an australian partnership and a
member firm of the KpmG network of
independent member firms affiliated with
KpmG international cooperative (“KpmG
international”), a swiss entity.
liability limited by a scheme approved under
professional standards legislation.
24 statEmEnt oF proFit or loss For thE yEar EndEd 31 dEcEmbEr 2013
rendering of services
Finance income
investing income / (expense)
other income
total revenue
Employee expenses
depreciation and amortisation expenses
occupancy expenses
systems and communication expenses
professional expenses
Finance expenses
other expenses
total expenses
results from operating activities
share of profit / (loss) of equity accounted investments, net of income tax
profit / (loss) before income tax
note
6.
9.
7.
8.
10.
15,16.
9.
Consolidated
$ ‘000
2013
142,590
14,826
719
942
restated*
2012
119,058
16,137
513
773
159,077
136,481
(102,249)
(1,199)
(13,330)
(15,279)
(2,860)
(5,328)
(8,378)
(148,623)
(88,268)
(1,534)
(14,996)
(15,320)
(2,540)
(7,398)
(10,202)
(140,258)
10,454
(3,777)
-
10,454
(248)
(4,025)
income tax (expense) / benefit
11.
(3,643)
836
profit / (loss) for the year
attriButaBle to:
Equity holders of the company
non-controlling interests
profit / (loss) for the year
earninGs per share:
Basic earnings per share (aud)
diluted earnings per share (aud)
* see note 17.
the notes on pages 29 to 63 are an integral part of these consolidated financial statements.
6,811
(3,189)
6,821
(10)
6,811
(2,758)
(431)
(3,189)
28.
28.
Cents
Cents
2.7
2.7
(1.2)
(1.2)
statEmEnt oF comprEhEnsivE incomE For thE yEar EndEd 31 dEcEmbEr 2013
25
profit / (loss) for the year
other comprehensive income
items that may are or may Be ClassiFied to proFit and loss
change in fair value of cash flow hedge
other comprehensive income for the year, net of tax
total comprehensive income for the year
attriButaBle to:
Equity holders of the company
non-controlling interests
total comprehensive income for the year
other movements in equity arising from transactions with owners as owners are set out in note 26.
* see note 17.
the notes on pages 29 to 63 are an integral part of these consolidated financial statements.
Consolidated
$ ‘000
2013
6,811
restated*
2012
(3,189)
13
13
170
170
6,824
(3,019)
6,834
(10)
6,824
(2,588)
(431)
(3,019)
26 statEmEnt oF Financial position as at 31 dEcEmbEr 2013
Consolidated
$ ‘000
note
2013
restated*
2012
assets
cash and cash equivalents
trade and other receivables
loans and advances
Financial assets
prepayments
total current assets
deferred tax assets
property, plant and equipment
goodwill
intangible assets
total non-current assets
total assets
liaBilities
trade and other payables
deposits and borrowings
current tax liabilities
derivatives
Employee benefits
provisions
total current liabilities
Employee benefits
total non-current liabilities
total liabilities
net assets
equity
contributed equity
other equity
reserves
non-controlling interests
retained earnings
total equity attributable to equity holders of the Company
* see note 17.
the notes on pages 29 to 63 are an integral part of these consolidated financial statements.
12.
13.
19.
14.
18.
15.
16.
16.
20.
21.
22.
30.
24.
23.
24.
26.
26.
26.
26.
146,298
72,720
171,696
976
673
107,720
72,685
147,120
2,249
553
392,363
330,327
9,761
1,725
130,413
2,366
144,265
536,628
144,227
192,548
1,919
45
14,652
450
9,517
2,356
130,413
2,104
144,390
474,717
109,647
175,768
495
58
9,624
450
353,841
296,042
2,684
2,684
356,525
180,103
2,478
2,478
298,520
176,197
164,284
164,284
1,806
(612)
4,314
10,311
180,103
2,764
(885)
3,947
6,087
176,197
statEmEnts oF changEs in Equity
27
share
Capital
$ ‘000
164,284
treasury
shares
reserve
$ ’000
(863)
share
Based
payments
reserve
$ ’000
non-
ControllinG
interests
$ ‘000
Cash
Flow
hedGe
reserve
$ ‘000
retained
earninGs
$ ‘000
other
equity
$ ‘000
-
-
-
-
-
-
(811)
-
240
-
-
restated*
Balance at 1 January 2012
total Comprehensive inCome
profit / (loss) for the year
other Comprehensive inCome
change in fair value
of cash flow hedges
total other comprehensive income
total comprehensive
income for the year
-
-
-
-
transaCtions with owners, direCtly in equity
increase / (decrease) in
non-controlling interests
transfer of retained earnings
purchase of treasury shares
share based payments
Employee share awards exercised
increase / (decrease) in other equity
dividends
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Balance at 31 december 2012
164,284
(1,434)
Balance at 1 January 2013
164,284
(1,434)
total Comprehensive inCome
profit / (loss) for the year
other Comprehensive inCome
change in fair value
of cash flow hedges
total other comprehensive income
total comprehensive
income for the year
-
-
-
-
transaCtions with owners, direCtly in equity
increase / (decrease) in
non-controlling interests
transfer of retained earnings
share based payments
purchase of treasury shares
Employee share awards exercised
increase / (decrease) in other equity
dividends
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
(465)
213
-
-
8
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
840
(240)
-
-
608
608
-
-
-
-
-
-
724
-
(213)
-
-
total
equity
$ ‘000
174,641
(3,189)
170
170
(3,019)
4,378
-
(811)
840
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
4,378
(431)
-
-
-
-
-
(228)
11,440
-
(3,189)
170
170
170
-
-
(3,189)
-
431
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
2,764
2,764
(2,596)
-
(2,596)
3,947
(58)
6,086
2,764
176,197
3,947
(58)
6,086
2,764
176,197
-
-
-
-
377
(10)
-
-
-
-
-
-
13
13
13
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
6,811
-
-
6,811
-
10
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
(958)
6,811
13
13
6,824
377
-
724
(465)
-
(958)
(2,596)
10,311
-
(2,596)
1,806
180,103
Balance at 31 december 2013
164,284
(1,686)
1,119
4,314
(45)
* see note 17.
the notes on pages 29 to 63 are an integral part of these consolidated financial statements.
28 statEmEnt oF cash Flows For thE yEar EndEd 31 dEcEmbEr 2013
Consolidated
$ ‘000
note
2013
restated*
2012
Cash Flows From / (used in) operatinG aCtivities
cash receipts from customers and clients
cash paid to suppliers and employees
cash generated from operations 1.
dividends received
interest received
interest paid
income taxes paid
net cash from operating activities
25.
Cash Flows From / (used in) investinG aCtivities
net proceeds from sale of investments
acquisition of property, plant and equipment
acquisition of other investments
interest in equity accounted investees and non-controlling interests
net cash from / (used in) investing activities
Cash Flows From / (used in) FinanCinG aCtivities
dividends paid
on market share purchases
bell potter capital (margin lending)
deposits
loans
repayment of borrowings
net cash from / (used in) financing activities
net increase / (decrease) in cash and cash equivalents
cash and cash equivalents at 1 January
191,539
(150,254)
41,285
30
14,702
(5,328)
(2,463)
48,226
3,242
(189)
(1,252)
(592)
1,209
(2,596)
(465)
16,780
(24,576)
-
166,541
(157,837)
8,704
21
15,787
(7,398)
(678)
16,436
840
(460)
(504)
138
(14)
(2,596)
(811)
(6,635)
(8,623)
-
(10,857)
(18,665)
38,578
107,720
(2,215)
109,935
Cash and cash equivalents at 31 december
12, 25.
146,298
107,720
* see note 17.
the notes on pages 29 to 63 are an integral part of these consolidated financial statements.
1.
‘cash generated from operations’ relates to group cash reserves and client balances. refer to note 12 for further information
on cash and cash equivalents.
notEs to thE Financial statEmEnts For thE yEar EndEd 31 dEcEmbEr 2013
29
bell Financial group ltd (“bell Financial”
or the “company”) is domiciled in
australia. the address of the company’s
registered office is level 29, 101
collins street, melbourne, vic. the
consolidated financial statements of the
company comprise the company, its
subsidiaries and associates (the “group”
or “consolidated Entity”) and the group’s
interest in associates.
1. siGniFiCant
aCCountinG poliCies
set out below is a summary of significant
accounting policies adopted by the
company, its subsidiaries and associates
in the preparation of the consolidated
financial statements.
a) Basis of preparation
statement of compliance
the financial report is a general purpose
financial report prepared in accordance
with australian accounting standards
(aasBs) (including australian accounting
interpretations) adopted by the australian
accounting standards Board (aasB) and
the corporations act. the consolidated
financial report of the group and the
financial report of the company comply
with international Financial reporting
standards (iFrs) and interpretations
adopted by the international accounting
standards Board (iasB).
the financial statements were approved by
the Board of directors on 25 February 2014.
the accounting policies set out below,
except as noted, have been applied
consistently to all periods presented in
these consolidated financial statements,
and have been consistently applied by all
entities within the consolidated entity.
Basis of measurement
these consolidated financial statements
have been prepared under the historical
cost convention, except for financial
assets and liabilities (including derivative
instruments) at fair value through the
profit and loss.
Functional and presentation currency
investments in associates
associates are those entities in which
the company has significant influence,
but not control, over the financial and
operating policies. associates are
accounted for using the equity method.
the consolidated financial statements
include the group’s share of the income
and expenses of equity accounted
investees, from the date significant
influence commences until the date
that significant influence ceases. when
the group’s share of losses exceeds its
interest in an equity accounted investee,
the carrying amount of that interest is
reduced to nil.
unrealised gains arising from
transactions with equity accounted
investees are eliminated against the
investment to the extent of the group’s
interest in the investee. unrealised
losses are eliminated in the same way as
unrealised gains, but only to the extent
that there is no evidence of impairment.
special purpose entities
the group has established a special
purpose entity (spE) to manage margin
loans. the group does not have direct
or indirect shareholdings in this entity.
an spE is consolidated if, based on
an evaluation of the substance of its
relationship with the group and the spE’s
risks and rewards, the group concludes
that it controls the spE.
spE’s consolidated by the group were
established under terms that impose
strict limitations on the decision making
powers of the spE’s management and
that result in the group receiving the
majority of the benefits related to the
spE’s operations and net assets, being
exposed to risks incident to the spE’s
activities and retaining the majority of the
residual or ownership risks related to the
spE or its assets.
these consolidated financial statements
are presented in australian dollars, which
is the company’s functional currency and
the functional currency of the majority
of the group. the company is of a kind
referred to in asic class order 98/100
dated 10 July 1998 and in accordance with
that class order, all financial information
presented in australian dollars has been
rounded to the nearest thousand dollars
unless otherwise stated.
removal of parent entity
financial statements
the group has applied amendments to
the corporations act that remove the
requirement for the group to lodge parent
entity financial statements. parent entity
financial statements have been replaced
by the specific parent entity disclosures in
note 32.
b) principles of consolidation
Business combinations
the group has adopted revised aasB
3 Business combinations (2008) and
amended aasB 127 consolidated and
separate Financial statements (2008) for
business combinations occurring in the
financial year starting 1 January 2009. all
business combinations occurring before
this date are accounted for by applying
the acquisition method.
subsidiaries
subsidiaries are all entities controlled by
the group. the group controls an entity
when it is exposed to, or has rights to,
variable returns from its involvement
with the entity and has the ability to
affect those returns through its power
over the entity. the financial statements
of subsidiaries are included in the
consolidated financial statements from
the date that control commenced until the
date that control ceases. all controlled
entities have a 31 december balance date.
intra-group balances, and any unrealised
income and expenses arising from
intra-group transactions, are eliminated
in preparing the consolidated financial
statements.
30 notes to the Financial statements For the year enDeD 31 DecemBer 2013
1. siGniFiCant
e) income tax
tax consolidation
aCCountinG poliCies cont.
c) revenue recognition
revenue is recognised to the extent that it
is probable that the economic benefit will
flow to the group and the revenue can be
reliably measured. the following specific
criteria must also be met before revenue
can be recognised.
rendering of services
revenue arising from brokerage,
commissions, fee income and corporate
finance transactions are recognised by the
group on an accruals basis as and when
services have been provided, net of the
amount of goods and services tax (gst).
provision is made for uncollectible debts
arising from such services. securities held
at balance date are valued by directors at
market value at each balance date, with
any unrealised gains and losses being
taken to the income statement.
interest income
interest income is recognised as it accrues
using the effective interest rate method.
dividend income
dividends are brought to account as
revenue when the right to receive the
payment is established.
d) statement of Cash Flows
the statement of cash Flows is prepared
on the basis of net cash flows in relation
to settlement of trades. this is consistent
with the group’s revenue recognition
policy whereby the entity acts as an agent
and receives and pays funds on behalf
of its clients, however only recognises
as revenue, the group’s entitlement to
brokerage commission.
For the purpose of the statement of
cash Flows, cash and cash equivalents
comprise cash at bank and on hand,
investments in money market instruments
maturing within less than 14 days
(net of bank overdrafts) and short-term
deposits with an original maturity of
3 months or less. it is important to note
that the statement of Financial position
discloses trade debtors and payables that
represent net client accounts being the
accumulation of gross trading.
income tax expense or revenue for the
period comprises current and deferred tax.
income tax is recognised in the income
statement except to the extent that it relates
to items recognised directly in equity, in
which case it is recognised in equity.
current tax is the expected tax payable
on the taxable income for the year, using
tax rates enacted or substantially enacted
at the balance sheet date, and any
adjustments to tax payable in respect
of previous years.
deferred tax is recognised using the
balance sheet method, providing for
temporary differences between the
carrying amounts of assets and liabilities
for financial reporting purposes and the
amounts used for taxation purposes.
deferred tax is not recognised for the
following temporary differences: the
initial recognition of goodwill, the initial
recognition of assets or liabilities in
a transaction that is not a business
combination and that affects neither
accounting nor taxable profit, and
differences relating to investments
in subsidiaries to the extent that
they probably will not reverse in the
foreseeable future. deferred tax is
measured at the tax rates that are
expected to be applied to the temporary
differences when they reverse, based
on the laws that have been enacted
or substantively enacted by the
reporting date.
deferred tax assets and liabilities are
offset if there is a legally enforceable
right to offset current tax liabilities and
assets, and they relate to income taxes
levied by the same tax authority on the
same taxable entity, or on different tax
entities, but they intend to settle current
tax liabilities and assets on a net basis
or their tax assets and liabilities will be
realised simultaneously.
Effective 1 January 2003, the company
elected to apply the tax consolidation
legislation. all current tax amounts relating
to the group have been assumed by the
head entity of the tax-consolidated group,
Bell Financial group. deferred tax amounts
in relation to temporary differences are
allocated as if each entity continued to be a
taxable entity in its own right.
f) Goods and services tax
revenues, expenses and assets are
recognised net of the amount of goods
and services tax (gst), except where the
amount of gst incurred is not recoverable
from the australian tax office (ato). in
these circumstances the gst is recognised
as part of the cost of acquisition of the
asset or as part of an item of the expense.
receivables and payables are stated
with the amount of gst excluded. the
net amount of gst recoverable from,
or payable to, the ato is included as a
current asset or liability in the statement
of Financial position.
cash flows are included in the statement
of cash Flows on a gross basis. the gst
components of cash flows arising from
investing and financing activities that are
recoverable from, or payable to, the ato
are classified as operating cash flows.
g) Cash and cash equivalents
cash and cash equivalents comprise cash
balances, investments in money market
instruments maturing within less than 14
days and short-term deposits with original
maturity of less than three months. Bank
overdrafts that are repayable on demand
are included as a component of cash and
cash equivalents for the purpose of the
statement of cash Flows. cash held in
trust for clients is included as cash and
cash equivalents and is included within
trade and other payables.
a deferred tax asset is recognised to
the extent that it is probable that future
taxable profits will be available against
which temporary differences can be
utilised. deferred tax assets are reviewed
at each reporting date and are reduced to
the extent that it is no longer probable that
the related tax benefit will be realised.
h) derivatives
derivative financial instruments are
contracts whose value is derived from one
or more underlying price indices or other
variable. they include swaps, forward rate
agreements, options or a combination of
all three.
notes to the Financial statements For the year enDeD 31 DecemBer 2013
31
certain derivative instruments are held
for trading for the purpose of making
short-term gains. these derivatives do not
qualify for hedge accounting. the right to
receive options arising from the provision
of services to corporate fee clients are
valued using the Black scholes model.
on disposal of options any realised gains/
losses are taken to the income statement.
derivatives are recognised initially at fair
value and attributable transaction costs are
recognised in profit or loss when incurred.
derivative financial instruments are also
used for hedging purposes to mitigate
the group’s exposure to interest rate
risk. derivative financial instruments are
recognised initially at fair value. where
the derivative is designated effective as
a hedging instrument, the timing of the
recognition of any resultant gain or loss
is dependant on the hedging designation.
the group designated interest rate swaps
as cash flow hedges during the period.
details of the hedging instruments are
outlined below:
Cash flow hedges
changes in the fair value of cash flow
hedges are recognised directly in equity to
the extent that the hedges are effective. to
the extent hedges are ineffective, changes
in the fair value are recognised in the profit
and loss. hedge effectiveness is tested at
each reporting date and is calculated using
the dollar offset method. Effectiveness
will be assessed on a cumulative basis
by calculating the change in fair value of
the interest rate swap as a percentage of
the change in fair value of the designated
hedge item. if the ratio change in the fair
value is within the 80 – 125% range, a
hedge is deemed to be effective.
if the hedging instrument no longer
meets the criteria for hedge accounting,
expires or is sold, terminated or
exercised, the hedge accounting
is discontinued prospectively. the
cumulative gain or loss previously
recognised in equity remains there until
the forecast transaction occurs.
i) impairment of assets
l) leased assets
at each reporting date, the group reviews
the carrying values of its tangible and
intangible assets to determine whether
there is any indication that those assets
have been impaired. if such an indication
exists, the recoverable amount of the
asset, being the higher of the asset’s fair
value less costs to sell and value in use,
is compared to the asset’s carrying value.
any excess of the asset’s carrying value
over its recoverable amount is expensed
to the income statement.
where it is not possible to estimate the
recoverable amount of an individual asset,
the group estimates the recoverable
amount of the cash-generating unit to
which the asset belongs.
an impairment loss, with the exception of
goodwill, is reversed if the reversal can be
related objectively to an event occurring
after the impairment loss was recognised.
For financial assets measured at
amortised cost and available-for-sale
financial assets that are debt securities
the reversal is recognised in profit or loss.
For available-for-sale financial assets
that are equity securities, the reversal is
recognised in equity. impairment losses
on goodwill are not reversed.
j) trade and other receivables
trade debtors to be settled within 3
trading days are carried at amounts due.
term debtors are carried at the amount
due. the collectability of debts is assessed
at balance date and specific provision is
made for any doubtful accounts.
leases in terms of which the group
assumes substantially all the risks and
rewards of ownership are classified as
finance leases. upon initial recognition
the leased asset is measured at an
amount equal to the lower of its fair
value and the present value of minimum
lease payments. subsequent to initial
recognition, the asset is accounted for
in accordance with the accounting policy
applicable to that asset.
other leases are operating leases and are
not recognised on the group’s statement
of Financial position.
m) Borrowing costs
Borrowing costs are recognised as expenses
in the period in which they are incurred.
n) provisions
a provision is recognised if, as a result
of a past event, the group has a present
legal or constructive obligation that can
be estimated reliably, and it is probable
that an outflow of economic benefits
will be required to settle the obligation.
provisions are determined by discounting
the expected future cash flows at a
pre-tax rate that reflects current market
assessments of the time value of money
and the risks specific to the liability.
o) deposits and borrowings
all deposits and borrowings are
recognised at cost, being the fair value
of the consideration received net of issue
costs associated with the borrowings.
k) trade and other payables
liabilities for trade creditors and other
amounts are carried at cost which is the
fair value of the consideration to be paid in
the future for goods and services received,
whether or not billed to the parent entity
or group. trade accounts payable are
normally settled within 60 days.
p) Goodwill and intangible assets
Goodwill
goodwill on acquisition is initially
measured at cost being the excess of the
costs of the business combination over
the acquirer’s interest in the net fair value
of the identifiable assets, liabilities and
contingent liabilities.
32 notes to the Financial statements For the year enDeD 31 DecemBer 2013
1. siGniFiCant
aCCountinG poliCies cont.
Financial assets at fair value
through profit or loss
p) Goodwill and intangible assets cont.
Following initial recognition, goodwill
is measured at cost less accumulated
impairment losses. goodwill is reviewed
for impairment, annually or more
frequently if events or changes in
circumstances indicate that the carrying
amount is impaired. an impairment loss
in respect to goodwill is not reversed.
other intangible assets
other intangible assets that are acquired
by the group, which have finite lives,
are measured at cost less accumulated
amortisation and accumulated
impairment losses.
amortisation is recognised in the profit
and loss on a straight-line basis over the
estimated useful lives of intangible assets.
the estimated useful lives are as follows:
a financial asset is classified in this
category if acquired principally for the
purpose of selling in the short term or if
so designated by management and within
the requirements of aasB 139 Recognition
and Measurement of Financial Instruments.
realised and unrealised gains and losses
arising from changes in the fair value of
these assets are included in the income
statement in the period in which they
arise.
items of property, plant and equipment
are depreciated/amortised using the
straight-line method over their estimated
useful lives. the depreciation rates for
each class of asset are as follows:
leasehold
improvements
2013
2012
20 – 25%
20 – 25%
office equipment
20 – 50%
20 – 50%
Furniture
and fittings
20 – 50%
20 – 50%
loans and advances
all loans and advances are recognised at
amortised cost. impairment assessments
are performed at least at each reporting
date and impairment is reviewed on each
individual loan. impairment provisions are
raised if the recoverable amount is less than
the carrying value of the loan. loans are
secured by holding equities as collateral.
s) employee entitlements
wages, salaries and annual leave
the provisions for entitlements to wages,
salaries and annual leave expected to be
settled within 12 months of reporting date
represent the amounts which the group
has a present obligation to pay resulting
from employees’ services provided up to
reporting date.
customer list
10 years
10 years
2013
2012
share capital
ordinary shares
q) Financial instruments
all investments are initially recognised
at fair value of the consideration given,
plus directly attributable transaction
costs. subsequent to initial recognition,
investments, which are classified
as financial assets are measured as
described below.
Fair value estimation
For investments actively traded in
organised financial markets, fair value is
determined by reference to stock Exchange
quoted market bid prices at the close of
business on the balance sheet date.
For investments where there is no quoted
market price and a reliable estimate of
fair value is not available the security
is recorded at the lower of cost and
recoverable amount, being a directors’
valuation, by reference to the current
market value of another instrument that
is substantially the same. realised and
unrealised gains and losses are included
in the income statement. dividends are
brought to account when declared.
ordinary shares are classified as equity.
incremental costs directly attributable
to issue of ordinary shares and share
options are recognised as a deduction
from equity, net of any tax effects.
dividends
dividends are recognised as a liability
in the period in which they are declared,
being appropriately authorised and no
longer at the discretion of the company.
treasury shares
when share capital recognised as
equity is repurchased, the amount of
the consideration paid is recognised as
a deduction from equity. repurchased
shares are classified as treasury shares
and are presented in the reserve until
sold or reissued.
r) property, plant and equipment
property, plant and equipment is included
at cost less accumulated depreciation
and any impairment in value. all property,
plant and equipment is depreciated over
its estimated useful life, commencing from
the time assets are held ready for use.
long-service leave
the provision for salaried employee
entitlements to long-service leave
represents the present value of the
estimated future cash outflows to be
made resulting from employees service
provided up to reporting date. liabilities
for employee entitlements, which are
not expected to be settled within twelve
months, are discounted using the
rates attaching to national government
securities at balance date, which most
closely match the terms of maturity of the
related liabilities.
in determining the liability for employee
entitlements, consideration has been
given to future increases in wage and
salary rates, and experience with staff
departures. related on-costs have also
been included in the liability.
Bonuses
the company recognises a liability
and an expense for bonuses. the
company recognises a provision where
contractually obliged or where there is
a past performance that has created a
constructive obligation.
notes to the Financial statements For the year enDeD 31 DecemBer 2013
33
defined contribution plans
u) Foreign currency transactions
a defined contribution plan is a post-
employment benefit plan under which the
company pays fixed contributions into
a separate entity and will have no legal
or constructive obligation to pay further
amounts. obligations for contributions to
defined contribution plans are recognised
as an employee expense in profit or loss
when they are due.
share-based payments
the company has adopted a number
of share-based Equity incentive plans
in which employees and directors
participate. the grant date fair value of
shares expected to be issued under the
various Equity incentive plans, including
options, granted to employees and
directors is recognised as an employee
expense, with a corresponding increase
in equity over the period in which the
employees become unconditionally
entitled to the shares.
the fair value of options at grant date
is independently determined using the
Black scholes option pricing model
that takes into account the exercise
price, the vesting period, the vesting
and performance criteria, the impact
of dilution, the share price at grant
date and the expected price volatility of
the underlying share and the risk free
interest rate for the vesting period.
t) earnings per share
the group presents basic and diluted
Earnings per share (Eps) data for its
ordinary shares.
Basic earnings per share
Basic Eps is calculated by dividing the
profit or loss attributable to ordinary
shareholders of the company by the
weighted average number of ordinary
shares outstanding during the period.
diluted earnings per share
diluted Eps is determined by adjusting
the profit or loss attributable to ordinary
shareholders and the weighted average
number of ordinary shares outstanding
for the effects of all dilutive potential
ordinary shares and share options
granted to employees and directors.
transactions in foreign currencies are
translated to the functional currency
of the group at exchange rates at the
date of the transaction. monetary assets
and liabilities denominated in foreign
currencies at the reporting date are
retranslated to the functional currency
at the foreign exchange rate at that date.
non-monetary assets and liabilities
denominated in foreign currencies
that are measured at fair value are
retranslated to the functional currency at
the exchange rate at the date that the fair
value was determined.
Foreign currency differences arising on
retranslation are recognised in profit or
loss, except for differences arising on
available for sale equity instruments that
are recognised directly in equity.
v) segment reporting
the group determines and presents
operating segments based on the
information that is internally provided to
the chief decision maker in accordance
with aasB 8 Operating Segments.
an operating segment is a component
of the group that engages in business
activities from which it may earn revenues
and incur expenses, including revenues
and expenses that relate to transactions
with any of the group’s other components.
an operating segment’s results are
reviewed regularly by management to
make decisions about resources to be
allocated to the segment and assess its
performance. segment results that are
reported to management include items
directly attributable to a segment as well
as to those that can be allocated on a
reasonable basis.
w) new standards and interpretations
not yet adopted
a number of new standards, amendments
to standards and interpretations are
effective for annual periods beginning
after 1 January 2013, and have not been
applied in preparing these consolidated
financial statements. those which may be
relevant to the group are set out below.
the group does not plan to adopt these
standards early.
aasB 9 Financial Instruments (2010),
aasB 9 Financial Instruments (2009)
aasB 9 (2009) introduces new
requirements for the classification and
measurement of financial assets. under
aasB 9 (2009), financial assets are
classified and measured based on the
business model in which they are held and
the characteristics of their contractual
cash flows. aasB 9 (2010) introduces
additions relating to financial liabilities.
the iasB currently has an active project
that may result in limited amendments
to the classification and measurement
requirements of aasB 9 and add new
requirements to address the impairment
of financial assets and hedge accounting.
aasB 9 (2010 and 2009) are effective for
annual periods beginning on or after
1 January 2015 with early adoption
permitted. the adoption of aasB 9 (2010)
is expected to have an impact on the
group’s financial assets, but no impact on
the group’s financial liabilities.
x) Changes in accounting policies
Except for the changes below, the group
has consistently applied the accounting
policies set out in note 1 to all periods
presented in these consolidated financial
statements.
the group has adopted the following new
standards and amendments to standards,
including any consequential amendments
in other standards, with a date of initial
application of 1 January 2013.
i) aasB 10 Consolidated Financial
statements (2011)
as a result of aasB 10 (2011), the group
has changed its accounting policy for
determining whether it has control over
and consequently whether it consolidates
its investees. aasB 10 (2011) introduces
a new control model that focuses on
whether the group has power over an
investee, exposure or rights to variable
returns from its involvement with the
investee and ability to use its power to
affect those returns.
34 notes to the Financial statements For the year enDeD 31 DecemBer 2013
1. siGniFiCant
aCCountinG poliCies cont.
x) Changes in accounting policies cont.
i) aasB 10 Consolidated Financial
statements (2011) cont.
in accordance with transitional provisions
of aasB 10 (2011), the group reassessed
the control conclusion for its investees at 1
January 2013. as a consequence, the group
has changed its control conclusion in respect
of its investment in third party platform pty
ltd, which was previously accounted for as
an associate using the equity method. the
group has determined that it had control
over the investee on 28 may 2012. this is
because the group has held significantly
more voting rights of the investee than
any other vote holders. accordingly, the
group applied acquisition accounting to the
investment at 28 may 2012 and restated the
relevant amounts as if the investee had been
consolidated from that date. the quantitative
impact of the change is set out in note 17.
ii) aasB 13 Fair value measurement
aasB 13 establishes a single framework
for measuring fair value and making
disclosures about fair value measurements
when such measurements are required
or permitted by other iFrss. it unifies
the definition of fair value as the price
that would be received to sell an asset
or paid to transfer a liability in an orderly
transaction between market participants
at the measurement date. it replaces and
expands the disclosure requirements about
fair value measurements in other aasBs,
including aasB 7. as a result, the group
has included additional disclosures in this
regard (refer to note 30).
in accordance with the transitional
provisions of aasB 13, the group has
applied the new fair value measurement
guidance prospectively and has not
provided any comparative information
for new disclosures. notwithstanding
the above, the change had no significant
impact on the measurements of the
group’s assets and liabilities.
2. siGniFiCant aCCountinG
JudGements, estimates
and assumptions
in applying the group’s accounting
policies management continually
evaluates judgements, estimates and
assumptions based on experience and
other factors, including expectations of
future events that may have an impact
on the group. all judgements, estimates
and assumptions made are believed
to be reasonable based on the most
current set of circumstances available
to management and are reviewed on an
ongoing basis. actual results may differ
from the judgements, estimates and
assumptions. significant judgements,
estimates and assumptions made by
management in the preparation of these
financial statements are outlined below:
recovery of deferred tax assets
deferred tax assets are recognised for
deductible temporary differences as
management considers that it is probable
that future taxable profits will be available
to utilise those temporary differences
(refer to note 19).
impairment of loans and advances
the company assesses impairment
of all loans at each reporting date by
evaluating any issues particular to an
asset that may lead to impairment. in the
directors’ opinion, no such impairment
exists beyond that provided at 31
december 2013 (refer to note 19).
long-service leave provisions
the liability for long-service leave is
recognised and measured as the present
value of the estimated future cash flows
to be made in respect of all employees at
balance date. in determining the present
value of a liability, attrition rates and pay
increases through promotion and inflation
have been taken into account. a discount
rate equal to the government bond rate
has been used in determining the present
value of the obligation (refer to note 24).
legal provision
as at 31 december 2013, a provision
has been accrued to reflect potential
claims. in the directors’ opinion, the
provision is appropriate to cover losses
that are quantifiable or measurable at
31 december 2013 (refer to note 23).
intangible assets
the customer lists acquired have been
valued using the net present value of the
unlevered free cash flow from each business’
client list and software development costs
acquired are initially measured at cost and
are amortised over the useful life. these
valuations are outlined below:
Bell Foreign exchange
and Futures business
the amortisation period for the acquired
intangible assets of the Foreign Exchange
and Futures business is deemed to be 10
years. this was determined by analysing
the average length of the relationship
clients have with the business.
Bell direct development Costs
the amortisation period for the acquired
intangible assets of the Bell direct
development costs is deemed to be 10
years. this was determined by analysing
the average length of the useful life.
impairment of goodwill
goodwill is tested for impairment
annually at 31 december 2013, or
more frequently if events or changes in
circumstances indicated that it might be
impaired. For the purpose of impairment
testing, goodwill is allocated to retail and
wholesale which represents the lowest
level at which it is monitored for internal
management purposes.
the recoverable amount of the business
to which each goodwill component is
allocated to a cash-generating unit is
estimated based on its value in use and
is determined by discounting the future
cash flows generated from continuing
use. at 31 december 2013, goodwill
allocated to the cash-generating units
was $57.5 million for retail and $72.9
million for the wholesale segment.
notes to the Financial statements For the year enDeD 31 DecemBer 2013
35
key assumptions used in discounted
cash flow projections
the assumptions used for determining
the recoverable amount are based on
past experience and expectations for the
future. projected cash flows for each group
of cash-generating units are discounted
using an appropriate discount rate and a
terminal value multiple is applied.
the following assumptions have been
used in determining the recoverable
amount of the all segments:
discount
rates
terminal
value
multiple
Brokerage
revenue
corporate
fee income
a range of discount rates
was used with 11.0% being
the mid-point of the range.
the discount rate is a post-
tax measure based on the
risk-free rate, adjusted for
a risk premium to reflect
both the increased risk of
investing in equities and
the systematic risk of the
specific business.
a range of terminal value
multiples was used with
7 times representing the
mid-point of the range. the
multiples were applied to
extrapolate the discounted
future maintainable after-
tax cash flows beyond the
five year forecast period.
an overall improvement in
average brokerage revenue
from current levels in both
the wholesale and retail
businesses.
an overall improvement in
corporate fee income as
market conditions improve.
sensitivity analysis
the recoverable amounts for the retail
and wholesale segments exceeds the
carrying values. the recoverable amounts
are sensitive to several key assumptions
and a change in these assumptions could
cause the carrying amounts to exceed the
recoverable amounts. using the mid-point
range above, if brokerage and corporate
fee revenue and communications and
system expenses (which are volume
based) decreases by approximately 6.5%
for retail and 17.5% for wholesale from
the estimated amounts, the estimated
recoverable amounts would be equal to
the carrying amounts. if the discount rate
increased to 15.5% for retail and 20% for
wholesale, the estimated recoverable
amounts would be equal to the carrying
amounts. Further, if the terminal value
multiple decreased to approximately 5.2
times for retail and 3.7 times for wholesale,
the estimated recoverable amounts would
be equal to the carrying amounts.
3. FinanCial risk manaGement
overview
the group’s principal financial
instruments comprise listed securities,
derivatives, term deposits and cash. the
group has exposure to the following risks
from its use of financial instruments:
■ market risk
■ credit risk
■ liquidity risk
risk management framework
the Board of directors has overall
responsibility for the establishment
and oversight of the risk management
framework. the Board has established
the group risk and audit committee,
which is responsible for developing and
monitoring risk management policies.
the committee reports regularly to the
Board of directors on its activities.
risk management policies are
established to identify and analyse
the risks faced by the group, to set
appropriate risk limits and controls,
and to monitor risks and adherence to
limits. risk management policies and
systems are reviewed regularly to reflect
changes in market conditions and the
group’s activities. the group, through its
training and management standards and
procedures, aims to develop a disciplined
and constructive control environment in
which all employees understand their
roles and obligations.
the group risk and audit committee
oversees how management monitors
compliance with the group’s risk
management policies and procedures
and reviews the adequacy of the risk
management framework in relation to
the risks faced by the group. internal
audit assists the group risk and audit
committee in its oversight role. internal
audit undertakes both regular and ad
hoc reviews of risk management controls
and procedures, the results of which
are reported to the group risk and
audit committee.
market risk
market risk is the risk that changes in
market prices, such as interest rates,
equity prices and foreign exchange rates
will affect the group’s income or the value
of its holdings of financial instruments.
the objective of market risk management
is to manage and control exposures
within acceptable parameters, while
optimising returns.
equity price risk
all instruments are subject to the risk
that future changes in market conditions
may make an instrument less valuable.
as trading instruments are valued with
reference to the market or Black scholes
model, changes in equity prices directly
affect reported income in each period.
the group continually monitors equity
price movements to ensure the impact on
the group’s activities is managed.
interest rate risk
interest rate risk arises from the potential
for change in interest rates to have
an adverse effect on the group’s net
earnings. the group continually monitors
movements in interest rates and manages
exposure accordingly.
the Board has also approved the use of
derivatives, in the form of interest rate
swaps, to mitigate its exposure to interest
rate risk. changes in the fair value and
effectiveness of interest rate swaps
(which are designated cash flow hedging
instruments) are monitored on a six-
monthly basis.
Currency risk
the group is exposed to currency risk
on monetary assets and liabilities held
in a currency other than the respective
functional currency of the group. the group
ensures the net exposure is kept to an
acceptable level by buying or selling foreign
currencies at spot rates where necessary to
address short-term imbalances.
36 notes to the Financial statements For the year enDeD 31 DecemBer 2013
margin lending
intangible assets
the fair value of intangible assets
acquired in a business combination is
based on the discounted cash flows
expected to be derived from the assets.
investments in equity
the fair values of financial assets at
fair value through profit and loss are
determined with reference to the quoted
bid price or if unquoted determined using
a valuation model at reporting date.
derivatives
the fair value of interest rate swaps
is based on a mark-to-market model
with reference to prevailing fixed and
floating interest rates. these quotes are
tested for reasonableness by discounting
estimated future cash flows based on
term to maturity of each contract and
using market interest rates for a similar
instrument at the measurement date.
the fair value of options is determined
using the Black scholes option-pricing
model.
share-based payments
the fair value of employee stock options
is determined using a Black scholes
model. measurement inputs include
share price, exercise price, volatility,
weighted average expected life of the
instrument, expected dividends and risk
free interest rate. service and non-
market conditions are not taken into
account in determining fair value.
management monitors exposure to credit
risk on an ongoing basis. the group
requires collateral in respect of margin
loans made in the course of business.
this collateral is generally in the form of
the underlying security the margin loan
is used to invest in. loan-to-value ratios
(lvrs) are assigned to determine the
amounts of lending allowed against each
security. loans balances are reviewed
daily and are subject to margin calls once
the geared value falls 10% lower than the
loan balance. warnings are sent between
5% and 10%.
Capital management
the Board’s policy is to maintain a
strong capital base so as to maintain
investor, creditor and market confidence
and to sustain future development
of the business. capital consists of
ordinary shares and retained earnings
of the group. the group is required to
comply with certain capital and liquidity
requirements imposed by regulators
as a licensed broking firm. all capital
requirements are monitored by the Board
and the group was in compliance with all
requirements throughout the year.
security arrangements
the anZ Bank has a registered
mortgage debenture over the assets and
undertakings of the company.
4. determination oF Fair values
a number of the group’s accounting
policies and disclosures require the
determination of fair value, for both
financial and non-financial assets
and liabilities. Fair values have been
determined and disclosed based
on the following methods. where
applicable, further information about the
assumptions made in determining fair
values is disclosed in the notes specific to
that asset or liability.
3. FinanCial risk
manaGement cont.
liquidity risk
liquidity risk is the risk that the group
will not be able to meet its financial
obligations as they fall due. the
group’s approach to managing this risk
is to ensure that it will always have
sufficient liquidity to meet its liabilities
when due, under both normal and
stressed conditions, without incurring
unacceptable losses or risking damage to
the group’s reputation.
ultimate responsibility for liquidity risk
management rests with the Board of
directors, which has built an appropriate
liquidity risk management framework
for the management of the group’s
short, medium and long-term funding
requirements. the group manages liquidity
by maintaining reserves, banking facilities
and reserve borrowing facilities and by
continuously monitoring forecast and
actual cash flows and matching up maturity
profiles of financial assets and liabilities.
with respect to the maturity of financial
liabilities, the group also:
■ holds financial assets for which there
is a liquid market and that they are
readily saleable to meet liquidity
needs; and
■ has committed borrowing facilities or
other lines of credit that it can access
to meet liquidity needs.
Credit risk
credit risk is the financial loss to the
group if a debtor or counterparty to a
financial instrument fails to meet its
contractual obligations.
trade and other receivables
the credit risk for these accounts is that
financial assets recognised on the balance
sheet exceed their carrying amount, net
of any provisions for doubtful debts. in
relation to client debtors, the group’s
credit risk concentration is minimised
as transactions are settled on a delivery
versus payment basis with a settlement
regime of trade day plus three days.
notes to the Financial statements For the year enDeD 31 DecemBer 2013
37
5. seGment reportinG
Business segments
in order to more closely align with how operating results are reviewed and assessed, the group’s operating segments were changed
from 30 June 2013. comparative segment information has been restated accordingly. the segments reported below are consistent
with internal reporting provided to the chief decision makers:
■ retail – equities, futures, foreign exchange, corporate fee income, portfolio administration services, margin lending and deposits.
■ wholesale – equities and corporate fee income.
31 deCemBer 2013
revenue from operations
profit / (loss) after tax
segment assets
total assets
segment liabilities
total liabilities
other seGment details
interest revenue
interest expense
depreciation / amortisation
share of net losses of associates
restated
31 deCemBer 2012
revenue from operations
profit / (loss) after tax
segment assets
total assets
segment liabilities
total liabilities
other seGment details
interest revenue
interest expense
depreciation / amortisation
share of net losses of associates
Geographical segments
retail
2013
$ ‘000
124,709
4,734
456,494
456,494
351,973
351,973
14,826
(5,328)
(1,145)
-
retail
2012
$ ‘000
110,871
(2,276)
394,187
394,187
295,660
295,660
16,137
(7,398)
(1,340)
-
wholesale
2013
$ ‘000
other
2013
$ ‘000
Consolidated
2013
$ ‘000
34,368
2,077
80,134
80,134
4,552
4,552
-
-
(54)
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
159,077
6,811
536,628
536,628
356,525
356,525
14,826
(5,328)
(1,199)
-
wholesale
2012
$ ‘000
other
2012
$ ‘000
Consolidated
2012
$ ‘000
25,610
(913)
80,530
80,530
2,860
2,860
-
-
(194)
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
(248)
136,481
(3,189)
474,717
474,717
298,520
298,520
16,137
(7,398)
(1,534)
(248)
the group operates predominantly within australia and has offices in hong Kong and london.
38 notes to the Financial statements For the year enDeD 31 DecemBer 2013
6. renderinG oF serviCes
Brokerage
Fee income
trailing commissions
portfolio administration fees
other
7. investinG inCome
dividends received
profit / (loss) on financial assets held at fair value through profit and loss
8. other inCome
Bad debts recovered
sundry income
9. FinanCe inCome and eXpenses
interest income on bank deposits
interest income on loans and advances
total finance income
Bank interest expense
interest expense on deposits
total finance expense
net finance income / (expense)
Consolidated
2013
$ ‘000
101,324
25,213
7,822
7,914
317
restated
2012
$ ‘000
86,580
18,441
6,544
7,188
304
142,590
119,058
Consolidated
2013
$ ‘000
30
689
719
restated
2012
$ ‘000
21
492
513
Consolidated
2013
$ ‘000
-
942
942
restated
2012
$ ‘000
4
769
773
Consolidated
2013
$ ‘000
2,458
12,368
14,826
(1,088)
(4,240)
(5,328)
9,498
restated
2012
$ ‘000
2,699
13,438
16,137
(1,530)
(5,868)
(7,398)
8,739
notes to the Financial statements For the year enDeD 31 DecemBer 2013
39
10. employee eXpenses
wages and salaries
superannuation
payroll tax
other employee expenses
Equity-settled share-based payments
11. inCome taX eXpense
Current taX eXpense
current period
taxable loss not taken up
adjustment for prior periods
deFerred taX eXpense
origination and reversal of temporary differences
total income tax expense / (benefit)
numerical reconciliation between tax-expense and pre-tax profit
accounting profit / (loss) before income tax
income tax using the company’s domestic tax rate of 30% (2012: 30%)
non-deductible expenses
adjustments in respect of current income tax of previous year
tax loss not taken up
Consolidated
2013
$ ‘000
(89,916)
(5,647)
(4,466)
(1,496)
(724)
restated
2012
$ ‘000
(76,413)
(5,945)
(3,905)
(1,166)
(839)
(102,249)
(88,268)
Consolidated
2013
$ ‘000
3,790
125
(41)
3,874
(231)
3,643
restated
2012
$ ‘000
104
242
(264)
82
(918)
(836)
Consolidated
2013
$ ‘000
10,454
3,136
423
(41)
125
3,643
restated
2012
$ ‘000
(4,025)
(1,207)
393
(264)
242
(836)
tax consolidation
Bell Financial group ltd and its wholly owned australian controlled entities are a tax-consolidated group.
40 notes to the Financial statements For the year enDeD 31 DecemBer 2013
12. Cash and Cash equivalents
cash on hand
cash at bank
short-term deposits
marGin lendinG Cash
cash at bank and short term deposits
Client Cash
cash at bank (trust account)
segregated cash at bank (client)
Consolidated
2013
$ ‘000
13
40,426
11,106
51,545
22,866
22,866
60,236
11,651
71,887
restated
2012
$ ‘000
13
30,136
11,387
41,536
30,593
30,593
25,225
10,366
35,591
Cash and cash equivalents in the statement of Cash Flows
146,298
107,720
Cash on hand, Cash at bank and short-term deposits represent Group cash reserves.
cash on hand and at bank earns interest at floating rates based on daily bank deposit rates. short-term deposits are made for
periods of between 7 days and 90 days.
segregated cash and trust bank balances earn interest at floating rates based on daily bank rates.
segregated cash and trust bank balances are restricted cash balances of the group. a corresponding liability is recognised within
trade and other payables (note 20).
the group’s exposure to interest rate risk for financial assets and liabilities is disclosed in note 30.
13. trade and other reCeivaBles
Current
trade debtors
less: provision for impairment
segregated deposits with clearing brokers
less : provision for impairment1
sundry debtors
the movement for the allowance in impairment in respect of loans and receivables during the year was as follows:
Balance at 1 January
Bad debts charged to income statement
Bad debts recovered
Balance at 31 december
Consolidated
2013
$ ‘000
61,973
(164)
61,809
9,250
(1,061)
8,189
2,722
72,720
1,095
130
-
1,225
restated
2012
$ ‘000
56,085
-
56,085
13,837
(1,095)
12,742
3,858
72,685
4
1,095
(4)
1,095
1. provisioning against receivables owed from mF global australia limited which was placed into administration late 2011.
notes to the Financial statements For the year enDeD 31 DecemBer 2013
41
14. FinanCial assets
FinanCial assets
Current (held at Fair value throuGh proFit and loss)
shares in listed corporations
unlisted options held for trading
15. property, plant and equipment
Consolidated
year ended 31 deCemBer 2013
Balance at 1 January 2013 (net accumulated depreciation)
additions
disposals
depreciation charge for the year
Balance at 31 december 2013
BalanCe at 1 January 2013
cost
accumulated depreciation
net carrying amount
BalanCe at 31 deCemBer 2013
cost
accumulated depreciation
net carrying amount
restated
Consolidated
year ended 31 deCemBer 2012
Balance at 1 January 2011 (net accumulated depreciation)
additions
disposals
depreciation charge for the year
Balance at 31 december 2012
BalanCe at 1 January 2012
cost
accumulated depreciation
net carrying amount
BalanCe at 31 deCemBer 2012
cost
accumulated depreciation
net carrying amount
Consolidated
2013
$ ‘000
472
504
976
restated
2012
$ ‘000
2,107
142
2,249
FiXtures and
FittinGs
$ ‘000
oFFiCe
equipment
$ ‘000
leasehold
improvements
$ ‘000
506
16
-
(103)
419
2,110
(1,604)
506
2,126
(1,707)
419
1,056
126
(29)
(479)
674
5,388
(4,332)
1,056
5,485
(4,811)
674
794
46
-
(208)
632
6,123
(5,329)
794
6,169
(5,537)
632
FiXtures and
FittinGs
$ ‘000
oFFiCe
equipment
$ ‘000
leasehold
improvements
$ ‘000
632
13
-
(139)
506
2,097
(1,465)
632
2,110
(1,604)
506
1,449
311
-
(704)
1,056
5,077
(3,628)
1,449
5,388
(4,332)
1,056
1,030
133
-
(369)
794
5,990
(4,960)
1,030
6,123
(5,329)
794
total
$ ‘000
2,356
188
(29)
(790)
1,725
13,621
(11,265)
2,356
13,780
(12,055)
1,725
total
$ ‘000
3,111
457
-
(1,212)
2,356
13,164
(10,053)
3,111
13,621
(11,265)
2,356
42 notes to the Financial statements For the year enDeD 31 DecemBer 2013
16. Goodwill and intanGiBle assets
year ended 31 deCemBer 2013
Balance at 1 January 2013
additions
amortisation
impairment
Balance at 31 december 2013
BalanCe at 1 January 2013
cost (gross carrying amount)
additions
accumulated amortisation
accumulated impairment
net carrying amount
BalanCe at 31 deCemBer 2013
cost (gross carrying amount)
additions
accumulated amortisation
accumulated impairment
net carrying amount
restated
31 deCemBer 2012
year ended 31 deCemBer 2012
Balance at 1 January 2012
additions
amortisation
impairment
Balance at 31 december 2012
BalanCe at 1 January 2012
cost (gross carrying amount)
accumulated amortisation
accumulated impairment
net carrying amount
BalanCe at 31 deCemBer 2012
cost (gross carrying amount)
additions
accumulated amortisation
accumulated impairment
net carrying amount
Consolidated
identiFiaBle
intanGiBles
$ ‘000
2,104
671
(409)
-
2,366
2,945
684
(1,525)
-
2,104
3,629
671
(1,934)
-
2,366
Goodwill
$ ‘000
130,413
-
-
-
130,413
130,413
-
-
-
130,413
130,413
-
-
-
130,413
Consolidated
identiFiaBle
intanGiBles
$ ‘000
Goodwill
$ ‘000
118,819
11,594
-
-
130,413
118,819
-
-
118,189
118,819
11,594
-
-
130,413
1,741
684
(321)
-
2,104
2,945
(1,204)
-
1,741
2,945
684
(1,525)
-
2,104
total
$ ‘000
132,517
671
(409)
-
132,779
133,358
684
(1,525)
-
132,517
134,042
671
(1,934)
-
132,779
total
$ ‘000
120,560
12,278
(321)
-
132,517
121,764
(1,204)
-
120,560
121,764
12,278
(1,525)
-
132,517
notes to the Financial statements For the year enDeD 31 DecemBer 2013
43
17. non-ControllinG interest (nCi)
the following table summarises the information relating to each of the group’s subsidiaries that has material nci, before any intra-
group eliminations. in 2013, the non-controlling interest in third party platform pty ltd was 48.77% (2012: 50.17%).
third party platForm pty ltd
non-current assets
current assets
non-current liabilities
current liabilities
net assets
carrying amount of nci
revenue
profit / (loss) after tax
total comprehensive income
profit allocated to nci
cash flows from operating activities
cash flows from investing activities
cash flows from financing activities
net increase / (decrease) in cash and cash equivalents
summary of quantitative impacts
2013
$’000
7,606
29,574
(212)
(28,122)
8,846
4,314
9,176
(21)
(21)
(10)
(351)
(32)
1,000
617
2012
$’000
7,089
29,111
(148)
(28,185)
7,867
3,947
3,406
(864)
(864)
(431)
(2,746)
(130)
2,333
(543)
the following table summarises the adjustments made to the group’s statement of Financial position at 31 december 2012 and the
statement of profit and loss for the year ended 31 december 2012 as a result of the consolidation of third party platform pty ltd.
there is no material change to the statement of changes in Equity or the statement of cash Flows.
statement of Financial position
intangible assets and goodwill
Equity accounted investees
trade and other receivables
property, plant and equipment
deferred tax asset
cash and cash equivalents
overall impact on total assets
trade and other payables
overall impact on total liabilities
non-controlling interest
other equity
overall impact on total equity
as previously
reported
$ ‘000
adJustments
$ ‘000
as restated
$ ‘000
120,264
12,750
196,655
2,243
3,199
104,560
-
270,186
-
-
-
-
12,253
(12,750)
25,952
113
6,318
3,160
35,046
28,334
28,334
3,947
2,764
6,711
132,517
-
222,607
2,356
9,517
107,720
-
298,520
-
-
-
-
44 notes to the Financial statements For the year enDeD 31 DecemBer 2013
17. non-ControllinG interest (nCi) cont.
statement of profit & loss
share in profit of equity accounted investees, net of tax
revenue
Expenses
tax expenses
overall impact on profit & loss
18. deFerred taX assets and liaBilities
deferred tax assets are attributable to the following:
as previously
reported
$ ‘000
adJustments
$ ‘000
as restated
$ ‘000
(681)
132,329
(135,155)
750
-
433
4,152
(5,103)
87
(431)
(248)
136,481
(140,258)
836
-
statement
oF FinanCial position
inCome statement
Consolidated
the BalanCe Comprises temporary diFFerenCes attriButaBle to:
depreciation
Employee benefits
tax losses
other items
gross deferred income tax assets
deferred income tax charge
2013
$ ‘000
213
1,678
6,184
1,686
9,761
restated
2012
$ ‘000
279
1,487
6,184
1,567
9,517
unrecognised deferred tax assets relating to tax losses at 31 december 2013: $377,000 (2012: $242,000)
19. loans and advanCes
current
margin lending
there were no impaired, past due or renegotiated loans at 31 december 2013 (2012:nil).
refer to note 30 for further detail on the margin lending loans.
2013
$ ‘000
(65)
192
-
117
244
restated
2012
$ ‘000
(75)
161
-
815
901
Consolidated
2013
$ ‘000
$ ‘000
171,696
171,696
restated
2012
$ ‘000
$ ‘000
147,120
147,120
notes to the Financial statements For the year enDeD 31 DecemBer 2013
45
20. trade and other payaBles
Current
settlement obligations
sundry creditors and accruals
segregated client liabilities
Consolidated
2013
$ ‘000
66,558
10,976
66,693
restated
2012
$ ‘000
62,623
9,618
37,406
144,227
109,647
settlement obligations are non-interest bearing and are normally settled on 3-day terms. sundry creditors are normally settled on
60-day terms.
21. deposits and BorrowinGs
this note provides information about the contractual terms of the group’s interest-bearing deposits and borrowings. For more
information about the group’s exposure to interest rate and foreign currency risk, see note 30.
Current liaBilities
deposits (cash account)1
cash advance facility2
Consolidated
2013
$ ‘000
162,824
29,724
192,548
restated
2012
$ ‘000
175,768
-
175,768
1. Borrowings relate to margin lending / cash account business (Bell potter capital) which are largely at call.
2. represents drawn funds from available Bell potter capital cash advance facility of $100m (2012:$100m).
interest rate risk exposures
details of the group’s exposure to interest rate changes on borrowings are set out in note 30.
terms and debt repayment schedule
terms and conditions of outstanding deposits and borrowings were as follows:
averaGe
eFFeCtive
interest rate
Consolidated
cash advance facility*
deposits (cash account)*
2013
3.03%
1.8%
2012
1.08%
2.5%
2013
restated
2012
year oF
maturity
2014
2014
FaCe value
$ ‘000
29,724
162,824
192,548
CarryinG
amount
$ ‘000
29,724
162,824
192,548
FaCe value
$ ‘000
-
175,768
175,768
CarryinG
amount
$ ‘000
-
175,768
175,768
* Borrowings relate to margin lending / cash account business (Bell potter capital) which are largely at call.
22. Current taX liaBilities
the current tax liability of the group is $1,918,987 (2012: $495,155). this amount represents the amount of income taxes payable in
respect of current and prior financial periods.
46 notes to the Financial statements For the year enDeD 31 DecemBer 2013
23. provisions
Current
legal provision
Balance at 1 January
arisinG durinG the year:
legal/other
utilised:
legal/other
Balance at 31 december
legal provision
Consolidated
2013
$ ‘000
450
450
2013
$ ‘000
450
-
-
450
restated
2012
$ ‘000
450
450
restated
2012
$ ‘000
750
-
(300)
450
this amount represents a provision for certain legal claims brought against the group. in the directors’ opinion, the provision is
appropriate to cover losses that are quantifiable or measurable at 31 december 2013.
24. employee BeneFits
Current
salaries and wages accrued
liability for annual leave
total employee benefits – current
non-Current
liability for long-service leave
total employee benefits – non-current
Consolidated
2013
$ ‘000
11,503
3,148
14,652
2,684
2,684
restated
2012
$ ‘000
6,778
2,846
9,624
2,478
2,478
the present value of employee entitlements not expected to be settled within twelve months of balance date have been calculated
using the following inputs or assumptions at the reporting date:
assumed rate of increase on wages / salaries
discount rate
settlement term (years)
number of employees at year end
Consolidated
2013
5.5%
2.6%
7
634
restated
2012
5.5%
3.1%
7
643
notes to the Financial statements For the year enDeD 31 DecemBer 2013
47
25. reConCiliation oF Cash Flows From operatinG aCtivities
Cash Flows From operatinG aCtivities
profit / (loss) after tax:
adjustments for:
depreciation & amortisation
doubtful debt provision
net (gain) / loss on investments
disposals of property, plant & equipment
share of losses of equity accounted investees
Equity settled share-based payments
(increase) / decrease current client receivables
(increase) / decrease current other receivables
(increase) / decrease other current assets
(increase) / decrease intangibles
(increase) / decrease deferred tax assets
increase / (decrease) current client payables
increase / (decrease) current other payables
increase / (decrease) current tax liabilities
increase / (decrease) current provisions
increase / (decrease) non-current payables
increase / (decrease) non-current provisions
net cash from operating activities
reconciliation of cash
For the purpose of the cash flow statement, cash and cash equivalents comprise:
cash on hand
cash at bank
short-term deposits
marGin lendinG Cash
cash at bank and short term deposits
Client Cash
cash at bank (trust account)
segregated cash at bank (client)
Consolidated
2013
$ ‘000
restated
2012
$ ‘000
6,811
(3,189)
1,199
130
(689)
29
-
724
8,204
(1,314)
1,135
(122)
(671)
(244)
33,223
1,357
1,424
5,028
-
206
1,534
1,095
(492)
-
249
839
36
(21,404)
(57)
(10)
(684)
(901)
34,550
2,746
(525)
2,654
(3)
34
48,226
16,436
2013
$ ‘000
13
40,426
11,106
51,545
22,866
22,866
60,236
11,651
71,887
restated
2012
$ ‘000
13
30,136
11,387
41,536
30,593
30,593
25,225
10,366
35,591
146,298
107,720
48 notes to the Financial statements For the year enDeD 31 DecemBer 2013
26. Capital and reserves
share capital
ordinary shares
on issue at 1 January
share issue
on issue at 31 december
movements in ordinary share capital
date
1 January 2012
details
opening balance
31 december 2012
Balance
1 January 2013
opening balance
31 december 2013
Balance
ordinary shares
Consolidated
2013
$ ‘000
164,284
-
2012
$ ‘000
164,284
-
164,284
164,284
numBer
oF shares
259,623,049
259,623,049
259,623,049
259,623,049
the authorised capital of the group is $164,283,700 representing 259,623,049 fully paid ordinary shares.
the holders of ordinary shares are entitled to receive dividends as declared from time to time and are entitled to one vote per share
at meetings of the company.
all ordinary shares rank equally with regard to the company’s residual assets.
treasury shares
as at 31 december 2013, there were 2,950,000 treasury shares outstanding (2012: 2,500,000).
retained earnings
as at 31 december 2013, there were retained profits of $10.3m (2012: $6.1m).
non-Controlling interests
the non-controlling interests relate to ownership of third party platform pty ltd at 48.77% (2012: 50.17%). Balance at 31 december 2013:
$4.3m (2012: $3.9m).
Cash flow hedging reserve
the cash flow hedging reserve comprises the effective portion of the cumulative net change in the fair value of the interest rate
swap related to hedged transactions. Balance at 31 december 2013: $45,000 (2012: $58,000).
share based payments reserve
the share based payments reserve arises on the grant of options, performance rights and deferred share rights to select employees
under the company’s equity-based remuneration plans. Balance at 31 december 2013: $1.1m (2012: $0.6m).
treasury shares reserve
the treasury shares reserve represents the cost of shares held by the Employee share trust that the group is required to include in
the consolidated financial statements. Balance at 31 december 2013: $1.7m (2012: $1.4m).
notes to the Financial statements For the year enDeD 31 DecemBer 2013
49
27. dividends
dividends recognised in the current year by the group are:
2013
interim 2013 ordinary dividend
Final 2013 ordinary dividend
2012
interim 2012 ordinary dividend
Final 2012 ordinary dividend
Cents per
share
total amount
$ ‘000
Franked /
unFranked
date oF payment
1.0
-
-
-
2,596
Franked
25 september 2013
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Company
2013
$ ‘000
2012
$ ‘000
dividend FrankinG aCCount
30 percent franking credits available to shareholders of Bell Financial group ltd for subsequent financial years
18,543
17,210
the above available amounts are based on the balance of the dividend franking account at year-end adjusted for:
1. Franking credits that will arise from the payment of current tax liabilities.
2. Franking debits that will arise from payment of dividends recognised as a liability at year-end.
3. Franking credits that will arise from the receipt of dividends recognised as receivable at year-end.
the ability to utilise the franking credits is dependent upon there being sufficient available profits to declare dividends.
the impact on the dividend franking account of dividends declared but not recognised as a liability is to reduce it by nil (2012: nil).
28. earninGs per share
Earnings per share at 31 december 2013 based on profit after tax and a weighted average number of shares outlined below was
2.7 cents (2012: (1.2) cents). diluted earnings per share at 31 december 2013 was 2.7 cents (2012: (1.2) cents).
reconciliation of earnings used in calculating eps
BasiC earninGs per share
profit / (loss) after tax
profit attributable to ordinary equity holders used for basic eps
adJustments For CalCulation oF diluted earninGs per share
profit attributable to ordinary equity holders used to calculate basic Eps
Effect of stock options issued
profit attributable to ordinary equity holders used for diluted eps
weighted average number of ordinary shares used as the denominator
weighted average number of ordinary shares used to calculate basic Eps (net of treasury shares)
weighted average number of ordinary shares at year-end
Consolidated
2013
$ ‘000
6,811
6,811
6,811
-
6,811
restated
2012
$ ‘000
(3,189)
(3,189)
(3,189)
-
(3,189)
Consolidated
2013
numBer
256,835,310
256,835,310
2012
numBer
258,464,804
258,464,804
weighted average number of ordinary shares used to calculate diluted eps
256,835,310
258,464,804
50 notes to the Financial statements For the year enDeD 31 DecemBer 2013
29. share-Based payments
long-term incentive plan (ltip)
the Board is responsible for administering the ltip rules and the terms and conditions of specific grants of options or performance
rights to participants in the ltip. the ltip rules include the following provisions:
■ the Board may determine which persons will be eligible to participate in the ltip from time to time. Eligible persons may
be invited to apply to participate in the ltip. the Board may in its discretion accept such applications.
■ a person participating in the ltip (“Executive”) may be granted options or performance rights on conditions determined by
the Board.
■ the options or performance rights will vest on, and become exercisable on or after, a date predetermined by the Board (“the
vesting date”), provided that the Executive remains employed as an executive of the company as at that date. these terms may
be accelerated at the discretion of the Board under specified circumstances.
■ an unvested option or performance right will generally lapse at the expiry of the exercise period applicable to that option or
performance right.
■ Following the vesting date, the vested option or performance right may be exercised by the Executive subject to any exercise
conditions and the payment of the exercise price (if any), and the Executive will then be allocated or issued shares on a one for
one basis.
■ the company has established an Employee share trust for the purpose of acquiring and holding shares in the company for the
benefit of participants.
Fair value of options granted
there were 23,750,000 share options granted during the year to 31 december 2013 (2012 : nil). the assessed fair value at grant date
of options issued in 2013 is $1,991,718. the fair value was determined using the Black scholes option-pricing model. an outline of
details and assumptions used in the valuation of share options granted is provided below:
Fair value oF share options and assumptions
Fair value at grant date
share price at grant date
Exercise price at grant date
option life (expected weighted average life)
Expected volatility (weighted average volatility)
risk-free interest rate (based on government bonds)
1. options can be exercised for a period of up to 12 months from exercise date.
the number and weighted average exercise prices of share options is as follows:
2013
$0.08386
$0.55
$0.80
28 may 20171
45.76%
2.62%
outstanding 1 January
granted during the year
Forfeited during period
outstanding 31 december
exercised 31 december
weiGhted
averaGe
eXerCise priCe
2013
-
$0.80
-
numBer oF
options
2013
-
23,750,000
(750,000)
$0.80
23,000,000
-
-
weiGhted
averaGe
eXerCise priCe
2012
numBer oF
options
2012
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
notes to the Financial statements For the year enDeD 31 DecemBer 2013
51
performance rights
under the ltip rules, performance rights are deferred equity taken as 100% shares, with the conditions, including vesting and the
period of deferral, governed by the terms of the grant. unvested performance rights are forfeited in certain situations set out in the
ltip rules. ordinary shares allocated under the ltip on exercise of performance rights may be held in trust beyond the deferral
period. the issue price for the 2011/2012 performance rights is based on the closing price of the shares traded on the asx on the
grant date. the issue price for the 2013 performance rights is based on the closing price of the shares traded on the asx on the
vesting date.
reconciliation of outstanding performance rights:
outstanding 1 January
granted during the year
Forfeited during the year
Exercised during the year
outstanding balance 31 december
expenses arising from share-based payment transactions
performance rights
total expense recognised as employee costs
30. FinanCial instruments
2013
$ ‘000
2,600
270
-
(431)
2,439
2012
$ ‘000
2,000
1,000
-
(400)
2,600
Consolidated
2013
$ ‘000
724
724
2012
$ ‘000
839
839
Exposure to credit, interest rate, currency and liquidity risks arise in the normal course of the group’s business.
Credit risk
management has a process in place to monitor the exposure to credit risk on an ongoing basis. the group requires collateral
in respect of margin loans made in the course of business within Bell potter capital. this collateral is generally in the form
of the underlying security the margin loan is used to invest in. a loan-to-value ratio (lvr) is determined for each security with
regard to market weight, index membership, liquidity, volatility, dividend yield, industry sector and advice from Bell Financial
group’s research department. a risk analyst performs a review of the lvr and the recommendation is submitted to management.
management does not expect any counterparty to fail to meet its obligations.
advisers and clients are provided with early warning of accounts in deficit from 5% up to 10% and clients receive a margin call if
their account is in deficit by more than 10%. margin calls are made based on the end-of-day position but can be made intraday at
management’s discretion.
the maximum exposure to credit risk is represented by the carrying amount of each financial asset in the statement of Financial
position as outlined below:
trade debtors
segregated deposits with clearing brokers
loans and advances
sundry debtors
Consolidated
restated
2013
$ ‘000
61,809
8,189
171,696
2,722
2012
$ ‘000
56,085
12,742
147,120
3,858
note
13.
13.
19.
13.
52 notes to the Financial statements For the year enDeD 31 DecemBer 2013
30. FinanCial instruments cont.
the ageing of trade receivables at reporting date is outlined below:
Consolidated
aGeinG oF reCeivaBles
not past due
past due 0 – 30 days
past due 31-365 days
more than one year
Gross
impairment
Gross
impairment
2013
$ ‘000
58,667
2,812
20
310
2013
$ ‘000
-
-
-
(164)
restated
2012
$ ‘000
restated
2012
$ ‘000
53,861
2,107
-
117
-
-
-
-
collectability of trade receivables is reviewed on an ongoing basis. debts that are known to be uncollectible are written off. a provision
for impairment of trade receivables is established when there is evidence that the company will not be able to collect all amounts due
according to the original terms. significant financial difficulties of the debtor, probability that the debtor will enter bankruptcy and default
or delinquency in payments (for amounts greater than 30 days overdue) are considered indicators that the trade receivable is impaired.
liquidity risk
the following are the contractual maturities of financial liabilities, including estimated interest excluding the impact of netting agreements.
Consolidated
2013
CarryinG
amount
$ ‘000
ContraCted
CashFlow
$ ‘000
6-months or
less
$ ‘000
6-12
months
$ ‘000
1-2
years
$ ‘000
2-5
years
$ ‘000
5+
years
$ ‘000
non-derivative liaBilities
trade & other
payables
cash deposits
cash advance
facilities
derivative liaBilities
hedging
derivative
144,227
(144,227)
(144,227)
162,824
29,724
(162,824)
(29,724)
(162,824)
(29,724)
45
(45)
(45)
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
restated
Consolidated
2012
CarryinG
amount
$ ‘000
ContraCted
CashFlow
$ ‘000
6-months or
less
$ ‘000
6-12
months
$ ‘000
1-2
years
$ ‘000
2-5
years
$ ‘000
5+
years
$ ‘000
non-derivative liaBilities
trade & other
payables
cash deposits
cash advance
facilities
derivative liaBilities
hedging
derivative
109,647
(109,647)
(109,647)
175,768
(175,768)
(175,768)
-
58
-
-
(58)
(58)
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
the group manages liquidity by maintaining reserves, banking facilities and reserve borrowing facilities and by continuously
monitoring forecast and actual cash flows and matching up maturity profiles of financial assets and liabilities. rolling cash
projections are used to monitor cash flow requirements and optimise cash returns on investments. a bank facility is also available
to be drawn upon in order to meet both short and long-term liquidity requirements.
notes to the Financial statements For the year enDeD 31 DecemBer 2013
53
market risk
market risk is the risk that changes in market prices, such as interest rates, equity prices and foreign exchange rates will affect the
group’s income or the value of its holdings of financial instruments. the objective of market risk management is to manage and
control exposures within acceptable parameters, while optimising returns.
interest rate risk
the group’s investments in fixed-rate debt securities and its fixed-rate borrowings are exposed to a risk of change in their fair
value due to changes in interest rates. the group’s investments in variable-rate debt securities and its variable-rate borrowings
are exposed to a risk of change in cash flows due to changes in interest rates. interest rate swaps are used to hedge exposure to
fluctuations in interest rates. changes in the fair value of these derivative hedging instruments are recognised directly in equity to the
extent that the hedge is effective. to the extent the hedge is ineffective, changes in the fair value are recognised in profit and loss.
in managing interest rate risk the group aims to reduce the impact of short-term fluctuations on the group’s earnings. over the
longer-term, however, permanent changes in interest rates will have an impact on profit.
investments in equity securities and short-term receivables and payables are not exposed to interest rate risk.
equity price risk
all instruments are subject to the risk that future changes in market conditions may make an instrument less valuable. as trading
instruments are valued with reference to the market or Black scholes model, changes in equity prices directly affect reported
income each period. the group monitors equity price movements to ensure there is no material impact on the group’s activities.
the group is exposed to equity price risks through its listed and unlisted investments. these investments are classified as financial
assets or liabilities at fair value through the profit and loss.
Foreign currency risk
the group is exposed to insignificant currency risk on monetary assets and liabilities held in a currency other than the respective
functional currency of the group. the group ensures the net exposure is kept to an acceptable level by buying or selling foreign
currencies at spot rates where necessary to address short-term imbalances.
sensitivity analysis
interest rate risk
at 31 december 2013, it is estimated that a general decrease of one-percentage point in interest rates would decrease the group’s
profit before income tax by approximately $1.23 million (2012: $0.8 million increase to loss). interest rate swaps have been included
in this calculation. a general increase of one-percentage point in interest rates would have an equal but opposite effect.
equity price risk
at 31 december 2013, it is estimated that a 10% decrease in equity prices would decrease the group’s profit before income tax by
approximately $0.1 million (2012: $0.2 million increase to loss). a 10% increase in equity prices would have an equal but opposite effect.
54 notes to the Financial statements For the year enDeD 31 DecemBer 2013
30. FinanCial instruments cont.
effective interest rates
in respect of income-earning financial assets and interest-bearing financial liabilities, the following tables indicate their average
effective interest rates at the reporting date and the periods in which they mature.
averaGe
eFFeCtive
interest
rate
$ ‘000
Consolidated
note
FiXed rate instruments
2013
restated
2012
total
$ ‘000
6 months
or less
$ ‘000
6-12
months
$ ‘000
1-2
years
$ ‘000
2-5
years
$ ‘000
more than
5 years
$ ‘000
6 months
or less
$ ‘000
6-12
months
$ ‘000
1-2
years
$ ‘000
2-5
years
$ ‘000
more than
5 years
$ ‘000
cash and cash
equivalents
loans and
advances
deposits and
borrowings
cash advance
facility
12.
19.
21.
21.
3.39%
26,370
26,370
5.77%
45,470
45,349
-
121
3.71%
(14,588)
(14,238)
(350)
3.03%
(29,274)
(29,274)
-
27,978
28,207
(229)
variaBle rate instruments
cash and cash
equivalents
loans and
advances
deposits and
borrowings
12.
19.
21.
2.5%
119,928
119,928
6.58%
126,226
126,226
1.64%
(148,236)
(148,236)
97,918
97,918
-
-
-
-
Fair value measurements
a) accounting classifications and fair values
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
the following table shows the carrying amounts of financial assets and financial liabilities, including their levels in the fair value
hierarchy. it does not include fair value information of financial assets and financial liabilities not measured at fair value if the
carrying amount is a reasonable approximation of fair value.
31 deCemBer 2013
FinanCial assets measured at Fair value
Equity securities
FinanCial assets not measured at Fair value
trade and other receivables
cash and cash equivalents
loans and advances
FinanCial liaBilities measured at Fair value
interest rate swaps used for hedging
FinanCial liaBilities not measured at Fair value
trade and other payables
deposits and borrowings
CarryinG amount
desiGnated at
Fair value
$’000
Fair value
hedGinG
instruments
$’000
loans and
reCeivaBles
$’000
other
FinanCial
liaBilities
$’000
976
976
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
45
45
-
-
-
-
-
-
72,720
146,298
171,696
390,714
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
144,226
192,548
336,774
-
total
$’000
976
976
72,270
146,298
171,696
390,714
45
45
144,226
192,548
336,774
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
84,256
84,256
2.4%
(170,259)
(170,259)
(5,184)
(5,184)
Fair value
level 1
$’000
level 2
$’000
level 3
$’000
averaGe
eFFeCtive
interest
rate
$ ‘000
4.45%
6.31%
4.47%
1.08%
3.0%
7.18%
472
472
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
total
$ ‘000
41,530
48,235
(5,509)
-
66,190
98,885
504
504
45
45
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
41,530
48,235
(5,509)
-
66,190
98,885
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
total
$’000
976
976
45
45
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
notes to the Financial statements For the year enDeD 31 DecemBer 2013
55
41,530
48,235
(5,509)
-
total
$ ‘000
41,530
48,235
(5,509)
-
averaGe
eFFeCtive
interest
rate
$ ‘000
4.45%
6.31%
4.47%
1.08%
3.0%
7.18%
30. FinanCial instruments cont.
effective interest rates
averaGe
eFFeCtive
interest
rate
$ ‘000
Consolidated
note
FiXed rate instruments
in respect of income-earning financial assets and interest-bearing financial liabilities, the following tables indicate their average
effective interest rates at the reporting date and the periods in which they mature.
2013
-
-
-
-
-
-
total
$ ‘000
6 months
or less
$ ‘000
6-12
months
$ ‘000
1-2
years
$ ‘000
2-5
more than
years
$ ‘000
5 years
$ ‘000
cash and cash
equivalents
loans and
advances
deposits and
borrowings
cash advance
facility
cash and cash
equivalents
loans and
advances
deposits and
borrowings
12.
19.
21.
21.
12.
19.
21.
variaBle rate instruments
3.39%
26,370
26,370
5.77%
45,470
45,349
3.71%
(14,588)
(14,238)
121
(350)
3.03%
(29,274)
(29,274)
27,978
28,207
(229)
2.5%
119,928
119,928
6.58%
126,226
126,226
1.64%
(148,236)
(148,236)
97,918
97,918
Fair value measurements
a) accounting classifications and fair values
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
the following table shows the carrying amounts of financial assets and financial liabilities, including their levels in the fair value
hierarchy. it does not include fair value information of financial assets and financial liabilities not measured at fair value if the
carrying amount is a reasonable approximation of fair value.
FinanCial assets measured at Fair value
31 deCemBer 2013
Equity securities
FinanCial assets not measured at Fair value
trade and other receivables
cash and cash equivalents
loans and advances
FinanCial liaBilities measured at Fair value
interest rate swaps used for hedging
FinanCial liaBilities not measured at Fair value
trade and other payables
deposits and borrowings
976
976
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
45
45
72,720
146,298
171,696
390,714
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
144,226
192,548
336,774
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
total
$’000
976
976
72,270
146,298
171,696
390,714
45
45
144,226
192,548
336,774
-
2.4%
(170,259)
(170,259)
(5,184)
(5,184)
CarryinG amount
Fair value
hedGinG
desiGnated at
loans and
Fair value
instruments
reCeivaBles
$’000
$’000
$’000
other
FinanCial
liaBilities
$’000
Fair value
level 1
$’000
level 2
$’000
level 3
$’000
472
472
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
504
504
-
-
-
-
45
45
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
84,256
84,256
66,190
98,885
66,190
98,885
restated
2012
6 months
or less
$ ‘000
6-12
months
$ ‘000
1-2
years
$ ‘000
2-5
years
$ ‘000
more than
5 years
$ ‘000
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
total
$’000
976
976
-
-
-
-
45
45
-
-
-
-
56 notes to the Financial statements For the year enDeD 31 DecemBer 2013
30. FinanCial instruments cont.
restated
31 deCemBer 2012
FinanCial assets measured at Fair value
Equity securities
FinanCial assets not measured at Fair value
trade and other receivables
cash and cash equivalents
loans and advances
FinanCial liaBilities measured at Fair value
interest rate swaps used for hedging
FinanCial liaBilities not measured at Fair value
trade payables
deposits and borrowings
desiGnated at
Fair value
$’000
Fair value
hedGinG
instruments
$’000
loans and
reCeivaBles
$’000
other
FinanCial
liaBilities
$’000
2,249
2,249
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
58
58
-
-
-
-
-
72,685
107,720
147,120
327,525
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
109,647
175,768
285,415
b) accounting classifications and fair values
the following shows the valuation techniques used in measuring level 1, 2 and level 3 values, as well as the significant unobservable
inputs used.
level 1 – Equity securities – the valuation is based on quoted prices in active markets for identical assets and liabilities.
level 2 – Equity securities (unlisted options) – the valuation technique using observable inputs. the valuation is based on
Black scholes model.
level 3 – interest rate swaps – the fair values are based on broker quotes. similar contracts are traded in an active market
and the quotes reflect the actual transactions in similar instruments.
CarryinG amount
Fair value
total
$’000
2,249
2,249
72,685
107,720
147,120
327,525
58
58
109,647
175,768
285,415
level 1
$’000
level 2
$’000
level 3
$’000
2,107
2,107
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
142
142
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
58
58
total
$’000
2,249
2,249
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
58
58
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
notes to the Financial statements For the year enDeD 31 DecemBer 2013
57
CarryinG amount
Fair value
Fair value
hedGinG
desiGnated at
loans and
Fair value
instruments
reCeivaBles
$’000
$’000
$’000
other
FinanCial
liaBilities
$’000
level 1
$’000
level 2
$’000
level 3
$’000
2,107
2,107
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
142
142
-
-
-
-
58
58
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
30. FinanCial instruments cont.
restated
31 deCemBer 2012
Equity securities
FinanCial assets measured at Fair value
FinanCial assets not measured at Fair value
trade and other receivables
cash and cash equivalents
loans and advances
FinanCial liaBilities measured at Fair value
interest rate swaps used for hedging
FinanCial liaBilities not measured at Fair value
trade payables
deposits and borrowings
2,249
2,249
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
b) accounting classifications and fair values
inputs used.
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
58
58
72,685
107,720
147,120
327,525
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
109,647
175,768
285,415
total
$’000
2,249
2,249
72,685
107,720
147,120
327,525
58
58
109,647
175,768
285,415
the following shows the valuation techniques used in measuring level 1, 2 and level 3 values, as well as the significant unobservable
level 1 – Equity securities – the valuation is based on quoted prices in active markets for identical assets and liabilities.
level 2 – Equity securities (unlisted options) – the valuation technique using observable inputs. the valuation is based on
Black scholes model.
level 3 – interest rate swaps – the fair values are based on broker quotes. similar contracts are traded in an active market
and the quotes reflect the actual transactions in similar instruments.
total
$’000
2,249
2,249
-
-
-
-
58
58
-
-
-
58 notes to the Financial statements For the year enDeD 31 DecemBer 2013
31. operatinG lease Commitments
leases as lessee
Future minimum rental payments under the non-cancellable operating leases at 31 december are as follows:
less than one year
Between one and five years
more than five years
Consolidated
2013
$ ‘000
10,436
25,757
18,387
54,580
restated
2012
$ ‘000
10,495
31,042
24,393
65,930
the group has entered into commercial property leases for its office accommodation. these leases have a remaining life of up to
ten years. the group has no other capital or lease commitments.
32. parent entity disClosures
as at, and throughout the financial year ending 31 december 2013 the parent company of the group was Bell Financial group ltd.
results oF the parent entity
profit for the year
total comprehensive income for the year
FinanCial position oF parent entity at year end
current assets
non-current assets
total assets
current liabilities
total liabilities
total equity oF the parent entity ComprisinG oF:
contributed equity
reserves
retained earnings / (losses)
total equity
Company
2012
$ ‘000
3,798
3,798
357
154,207
154,564
4,922
4,922
164,284
981
(15,622)
149,642
2013
$ ‘000
808
808
261
156,579
156,840
8,728
8,728
164,284
(549)
(15,622)
148,112
notes to the Financial statements For the year enDeD 31 DecemBer 2013
59
33. related parties
the following were key management personnel of the group at any time during the reporting period:
eXeCutive direCtors
eXeCutives
non-eXeCutive direCtors
c Bell
a provan
l Bell
a Bell
r Fell
d davenport
p vine (resigned 19 July 2013)
c coleman
g cubbin
B wilson
B shanahan
key management personnel compensation
the key management personnel compensation comprised:
short-term employee benefits
other long-term benefits
post-employment benefits
termination benefits
share-based payments
Consolidated
2013
$
2012
$
3,416,791
3,375,873
-
187,033
-
29,351
-
224,262
-
-
3,633,175
3,600,135
loans to key management personnel and their related parties
details regarding loans outstanding at the reporting date to key management personnel and their related parties at any time in the
reporting period, are as follows:
direCtors
c Bell
a provan
c coleman
g cubbin
B wilson
B shanahan
eXeCutives
l Bell
a Bell
r Fell
d davenport
p vine
BalanCe
1 January
2013
$
BalanCe
31 deCemBer
2013
$
interest paid
and payaBle in
the reportinG
period
$
hiGhest
BalanCe in
period
$
1,721,850
2,039,163
125,839
2,132,129
-
-
-
-
1,245,787
944,559
64,457
1,366,504
-
-
-
68,473
223,476
65,147
46,122
134,494
-
-
-
137,144
211,286
259,616
54,565
136,104
-
-
-
3,720
13,282
15,259
3,337
4,819
-
-
-
163,177
408,412
351,481
54,565
138,526
60 notes to the Financial statements For the year enDeD 31 DecemBer 2013
33. related parties cont.
direCtors
c Bell
a provan
c coleman
g cubbin
m spry
B wilson
B shanahan
eXeCutives
l Bell
a Bell
r Fell
d davenport
p vine
BalanCe
1 January
2012
$
BalanCe
31 deCemBer
2012
$
interest paid
and payaBle in
the reportinG
period
$
hiGhest
BalanCe in
period
$
277,349
1,721,850
74,325
1,721,850
-
-
-
-
1,167,715
1,245,787
86,190
1,362,856
-
-
-
-
-
500,000
242,534
122,949
138,659
-
-
-
-
68,473
223,476
65,147
46,122
134,494
-
-
-
-
1,275
22,786
5,351
5,611
10,536
-
-
-
-
142,579
500,000
242,534
137,049
142,466
loans totalling $3,782,437 (2012: $3,505,349) were made to key management personnel and their related parties during the year.
the recipients of these loans were colin Bell, craig coleman, lewis Bell, andrew Bell, rowan Fell, dean davenport and paul vine.
the loans represent margin loans held with Bell potter capital limited. interest is payable at prevailing market rates. related
parties also have deposits on normal terms and conditions.
details regarding the aggregate of loans made, guaranteed or secured by any entity in the group to key management personnel and
their related parties, and the number of individuals in each group, are as follows:
total for key management personnel 2013
total for key management personnel 2012
total for other related parties 2013
total for other related parties 2012
openinG
BalanCe
$
3,505,349
2,449,206
-
-
ClosinG
BalanCe
$
3,782,437
3,505,349
-
-
total for key management personnel and their related parties 2013
total for key management personnel and their related parties 2012
3,505,349
2,449,206
3,782,437
3,505,349
interest paid
and payaBle in
the reportinG
period
$
numBer in
Group at
31 deCemBer
230,713
206,074
-
-
230,713
206,074
17
9
-
-
17
9
interest is payable at prevailing market rates on all loans to key management persons and their related entities. these rates are
available to all clients and may vary marginally depending on individual negotiations. the principal amounts are repayable per
terms agreed on an individual basis. interest received on the loans totalled $230,713 (2012: $206,074). no amounts have been
written-down or recorded as allowances for impairment, as the balances are considered fully collectible.
notes to the Financial statements For the year enDeD 31 DecemBer 2013
61
movements in shares 2013
the movement during the reporting period in the number of ordinary shares in Bell Financial group ltd held, directly, indirectly or
beneficially, by each director and key management person, including their related parties, is as follows:
direCtors
c Bell1
a provan1
c coleman
g cubbin
B wilson
B shanahan
eXeCutives
lm Bell1
ag Bell1
r Fell
d davenport
p vine
held at
1 January
2013
33,674,602
33,633,345
1,772,283
180,000
1,000,000
250,000
32,773,328
25,113,728
610,000
184,949
50,300
purChases
151,000
147,465
-
-
-
-
162,559
48,750
-
-
-
reCeived on
eXerCise oF
options
held at
31 deCemBer
2013
sales
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
33,825,602
33,780,810
1,722,283
180,000
1,000,000
250,000
32,935,887
25,162,478
610,000
184,949
50,300
1. the number of shares held by colin Bell, alastair provan, lewis Bell and andrew Bell includes those held indirectly through
Bell group holdings pty limited.
movements in shares 2012
direCtors
c Bell
a provan
c coleman
g cubbin
m spry
B wilson
B shanahan
eXeCutives
lm Bell
ag Bell
r Fell
d davenport
p vine
held at
1 January
2012
purChases
reCeived on
eXerCise oF
options
held at
31 deCemBer
2012
sales
33,089,642
32,958,386
1,772,283
180,000
150,000
100,000
-
32,369,919
24,862,478
610,000
184,949
50,300
584,960
674,959
-
-
-
900,000
250,000
403,409
251,250
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
(50,000)
-
-
-
-
-
-
33,674,602
33,633,345
1,772,283
180,000
100,000
1,000,000
250,000
32,773,328
25,113,728
610,000
184,949
50,300
62 notes to the Financial statements For the year enDeD 31 DecemBer 2013
33. related parties cont.
other key management personnel transactions
Bell Financial has an option to purchase the remaining shares of Bell direct from the current shareholders. the current
shareholders include directors of Bell Financial.
craig coleman, currently a non-executive director, provided consultancy services to Bell Financial and was paid $50,000 for those
services (2012: $165,000).
Brian wilson, currently a non-executive director, did not provide consultancy services to Bell Financial in 2013 (2012: $100,000).
there are no other transactions with key management persons or their related parties other than those that have been disclosed in
this report.
ultimate parent
Bell group holdings pty ltd is the ultimate parent company of Bell Financial group ltd. there are no outstanding amounts owed by
the ultimate parent entity at 31 december 2013 (2012: nil). there is no interest receivable at 31 december 2013 (2012: nil).
subsidiaries
the table below outlines loans made by the company to wholly owned subsidiaries.
suBsidiary
Bell potter Financial planning limited1
Bell potter investments pty limited1
Bell potter capital limited2
2013
$
2,136
-
8,149,244
8,151,380
2012
$
1,550
50,343
8,105,792
8,157,685
1. loan is interest free and unsecured.
2. the loan from the parent entity to Bell potter capital limited represents a subordinated loan that attracts interest at 3.74% per
annum (2012: 4.69% per annum).
loans made by wholly owned subsidiaries to the company: $14,303,871 (2012: $12,471,952)
during the course of the financial year subsidiaries conducted transactions with each other and associates on terms equivalent to
those on an arm’s length basis. they are fully eliminated on consolidation. as at 31 december 2013, all outstanding amounts are
considered fully collectable.
34. Group entities
parent entity
Bell FinanCial Group ltd
siGniFiCant suBsidiaries
Bell potter securities limited
Bell potter capital limited
third party platform pty ltd
Bell potter securities limited (uK)
Bell potter securities limited (hK)
Country oF ownership
interest
inCorporation
2013
2012
australia
australia
australia
united Kingdom
hong Kong
100%
100%
51.23%
100%
100%
100%
100%
49.83%
100%
100%
in the financial statements of the company investments in subsidiaries are accounted for at cost. the company has no jointly
controlled entities.
notes to the Financial statements For the year enDeD 31 DecemBer 2013
63
third party platform pty ltd
Following the introduction of aasB10 consolidated Financial statements, Bell Financial group reassessed when it acquired control
over third party platform pty ltd. the effective date of control has been determined as 28th may 2012. it was determined that Bell
Financial group does have control over third party platform pty ltd. the remaining voting rights are widely dispersed and there is
no indication that all other shareholders exercise their votes collectively.
35. Guarantees
From time to time Bell Financial has provided financial guarantees in the ordinary course of business which amount to $12.4m
(2012: $14.2m) and are not recorded in the statement of Financial position as at 31 december 2013.
36. ContinGent liaBilities and ContinGent assets
the company has agreed to indemnify its wholly owned subsidiary, Bell potter securities limited, in the event that any contingent
liabilities of Bell potter securities limited results in a loss.
37. suBsequent events
there were no significant events from 31 december 2013 to the date of this report other than:
Citi and Bell potter sign mou
on 20 February 2014, Bell Financial announced that it had signed a memorandum of understanding (mou) with citi. the
arrangement will see Bell potter’s retail and sophisticated investor clients provided with access to citi’s highly ranked global
research platform and securities products. the products will include equity offerings, equity-linked (hybrid instruments) and certain
fixed interest products. Bell potter’s retail clients will be able to access a research offering which combines citi’s resources of
highly rated research teams in EmEa, asia and the americas with Bell potter’s own predominantly small and medium capitalized
company research. the distribution and research agreement is being finalised and is intended to take effect in the coming weeks.
Bell Financial’s alliance with citi replaces the long-standing relationship the company has had with uBs. the strategic alliance
agreement had an initial term of three years from 12 december 2007 and was extended for a further three year term to 12
december 2013, then again to 28 February 2014. as at the date of this report, uBs owns 16.27% of the ordinary shares in the
company. on termination of the strategic alliance agreement, all of the company’s obligations to uBs regarding shareholder
restrictions, non-dilution rights and distribution exclusivity fall away.
Final dividend
on 25 February 2014, the directors resolved to pay a fully franked final dividend of 1.5 cents per share.
38. auditors’ remuneration
audit serviCes
auditors of the company
Kpmg australia:
audit and review of financial reports
total remuneration for audit services
audit related serviCes
auditors of the company
Kpmg australia:
other regulatory audit services
total remuneration for audit related services
non-audit related services
Consolidated
2013
$
restated
2012
$
402,000
402,000
385,200
385,200
93,000
93,000
-
495,000
93,110
93,110
700
479,010
64
dirEctors’ dEclaration
1.
in the opinion of the directors of Bell Financial group ltd (‘the company’):
a)
the consolidated financial statements and notes that are set out on pages 24 to 63 and the remuneration report on pages
15 to 21 in the directors’ report, are in accordance with the corporations act, including:
i)
giving a true and fair view of the group’s financial position as at 31 december 2013 and of its performance for the
financial year ended on that date; and
ii) complying with australian accounting standards and the corporations regulations 2001;
b) there are reasonable grounds to believe that the company will be able to pay its debts as and when they become due
and payable.
2. the directors have been given the declarations required by section 295a of the corporations act from the managing director
and chief Financial officer for the financial year ended 31 december 2013.
3. the directors draw attention to note 1(a) of the financial statements which includes a statement of compliance with
international Financial reporting standards.
signed in accordance with a resolution of the directors:
Colin Bell
Executive chairman
sydney
25 February 2014
indEpEndEnt auditor’s rEport
65
independent auditor’s report to the memBers oF Bell FinanCial Group limited
report on the FinanCial report
we have audited the accompanying financial report of Bell Financial group (the company), which comprises
the consolidated statement of financial position as at 31 december 2013, and consolidated income statement
and consolidated statement of comprehensive income, consolidated statement of changes in equity and
consolidated statement of cash flows for the year ended on that date, notes 1 to 38 comprising a summary
of significant accounting policies and other explanatory information and the directors’ declaration of the
group comprising the company and the entities it controlled at the year’s end or from time to time during the
financial year.
directors’ responsibility for the financial report
the directors of the company are responsible for the preparation of the financial report that gives a true and
fair view in accordance with australian accounting standards and the Corporations Act 2001 and for such
internal controls as the directors determine is necessary to enable the preparation of the financial report
that is free from material misstatement whether due to fraud or error. in note 1(a), the directors also state,
in accordance with australian accounting standard aasB 101 Presentation of Financial Statements, that the
financial statements of the group comply with international Financial reporting standards.
auditor’s responsibility
our responsibility is to express an opinion on the financial report based on our audit. we conducted our
audit in accordance with australian auditing standards. these auditing standards require that we comply
with relevant ethical requirements relating to audit engagements and plan and perform the audit to obtain
reasonable assurance whether the financial report is free from material misstatement.
an audit involves performing procedures to obtain audit evidence about the amounts and disclosures in the
financial report. the procedures selected depend on the auditor’s judgement, including the assessment of
the risks of material misstatement of the financial report, whether due to fraud or error. in making those risk
assessments, the auditor considers internal control relevant to the entity’s preparation of the financial report
that gives a true and fair view in order to design audit procedures that are appropriate in the circumstances,
but not for the purpose of expressing an opinion on the effectiveness of the entity’s internal controls. an audit
also includes evaluating the appropriateness of accounting policies used and the reasonableness of accounting
estimates made by the directors, as well as evaluating the overall presentation of the financial report.
we performed the procedures to assess whether in all material respects the financial report presents fairly, in
accordance with the Corporations Act 2001 and australian accounting standards, a true and fair view which is
consistent with our understanding of the group’s financial position and of its performance.
we believe that the audit evidence we have obtained is sufficient and appropriate to provide a basis for our
audit opinion.
KpmG, an australian partnership and a
member firm of the KpmG network of
independent member firms affiliated with
KpmG international cooperative (“KpmG
international”), a swiss entity.
liability limited by a scheme approved under
professional standards legislation.
66 inDepenDent auDitor’s report
independence
in conducting our audit, we have complied with the independence requirements of the Corporations Act 2001.
auditor’s opinion
in our opinion:
a) the financial report of the group is in accordance with the Corporations Act 2001, including:
i)
giving a true and fair view of the group’s financial position as at 31 december 2013 and of its
performance for the year ended on that date; and
ii) complying with australian accounting standards and the Corporations Regulations 2001.
b)
the financial report also complies with international Financial reporting standards as disclosed
in note 1(a).
report on the remuneration report
we have audited the remuneration report included in pages 15 to 21 of the directors’ report for the year ended
31 december 2013. the directors of the company are responsible for the preparation and presentation of the
remuneration report in accordance with section 300a of the Corporations Act 2001. our responsibility is to express
an opinion on the remuneration report, based on our audit conducted in accordance with auditing standards.
auditor’s opinion
in our opinion, the remuneration report of Bell Financial group for the year ended 31 december 2013,
complies with section 300a of the Corporations Act 2001.
Kpmg
dean m waters
partner
melbourne
25 February 2014
sharEholdEr inFormation
67
the shareholder information set out below was applicable as at 31 January 2014.
distriBution oF shares
ranGe
1 - 1,000
1,001 - 5,000
5,001 - 10,000
10,001 - 100,000
100,001 and over
rounding
total
unmarketaBle parCels
minimum $500.00 parcel at $ 0.65 per unit
twenty larGest shareholders
rank name
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
Bell group holdings pty limited
uBs nominees pty ltd
rBc investor services australia nominees pty limited
Continue reading text version or see original annual report in PDF format above